The fatwa factory of Darul Uloom Deo-Band has issued a
Verdict against this Nalayak
see http://darulifta-deoband.org/viewfatwa.jsp?ID=7077
Question: 7077 |
Afghanistan |
Asalamu Alikum wb our respected scholars of Islam, My question is regarding the famous daee of Islam Dr.Zakir Naik whether the method & way of his preaching,debating, studing different religons’ scriptures are valid in the light of Quran & Hadith or not, and should Muslims learn his Dawah techniques or not? what are the particular things in his work that are against Islam? please send me a private email. |
|
(Fatwa: 1541/1322=B/1429)The statements made by Dr Zakir Naik indicate that he is a preacher of Ghair Muqallidin, he is of free mind and does not wear Islamic dress. One should not rely upon his speeches. |
and Allah (Subhana Wa Ta’ala) Knows Best
|
Q– Kindly also thru light on the knowledge & working of Dr. Zakir Naik who is famous for his comparative religion lectures & debates, also runs a Tv channel by the name of PEACE TV. JazakAllah Wa Assalaam
Ans
We do not have details about Dr. Zakir Naik, only we know that he is an agent of Ghair Muqallideen, away from knowledge and wisdom, spreading mischievous things and misguiding simple Muslims to wrong path.
Darul Uloom Denies the Fatwa About Cow
Slaughter Published in Newspapers
Darul Uloom Deoband: 26/04/1429 H
Mufti Habibur Rahman Sahib, the head of Darul-Ifta Darul Uloom Deoband, has refused explicitly the so-called fatwa published in newspapers explaining that he had issued no such kind of Fatwa which pronounced slaughtering cow, selling and eating its meat as haram.
The Mufti Sahib declared the news published in Dainik Jagran on 26 April 2008 as baseless and false.
Making it clear, he said that a person from Muzuffarnagar (UP) had asked over the phone weather the act of those slaughtering cow secretly and eating it was Islamically lawful or unlawful. He replied him over the phone saying: “In the light of the Shariah, eating meat of cow is permissible but people of the States where cow slaughter is banned should avoid it as slaughtering cow and eating its meat stealthily is unsuitable and wrong.”
Haider
gk121105
sarfrazpatil
141 responses so far ↓
amin rafiq shaikh // June 28, 2008 at 6:10 pm |
the spelling which used is incorrect plz rectifed the spelling because wrong spelling will change the meaning of the word and the specialy the spelling which is use in writting the name of the khalifa plz do the needfully for that
Moinuddin Pathan Ahmedabad // July 14, 2008 at 12:57 pm |
The Deobandhi people has nothing to do
that’s y they have open a factory of Fatwa
stainly // July 19, 2008 at 7:13 am |
Yes Brother Moinuddin Pathan, you are right they are issuing Fatwa just like chatting on shadi.com
raja // July 29, 2008 at 11:15 am |
the mufti has said zakir naik is misguiding the simple muslims. From what i can see he is a person of truth and knowledge and backs up all his statements unlike thecomment of the muft.
Khanum // August 9, 2008 at 8:52 pm |
Allah has made it clear in the Quran that he doesn’t want us to be divided. He said, “hold to the rope of allah and do not be divided”. Now when I talk to “sect sensitive” people they reply, ” He divided us himself”
Ofcourse they misunderstand God and its a pity. He divided us into colors and races to test us and ordered us to remain united. Scholars like Dr. Zakir Naik and Ahmed Deedat are the ones who see and understand this point. I believe if anyone of us is against such scholars, He is either useless himself or just cannot stand the fact that such scholars provide truth which doesnt go down there throats.
Please show some tolerance. If u dont like any comment made by Zakir naik then atleast remember all the efforts he’s doing for Muslims. He’s a great Daa’ee no doubt. Explore the facts urself and then come to a decision. see both sides of the picture. Most of us make mistakes when we do not study ourselves and then blame others.
And Allah knows the Best.
Rakib Malik // August 24, 2008 at 5:10 pm |
I love Zakir Naik very much not for that I’m a muslim He’s simply a genius.
mohammed affan ahmed siddiqui // September 11, 2008 at 8:17 am |
ASALK
BROTHER I HAVE ALWAYS FEAR ABOUT THE THINGS WHICH IS HAPPENING IN INDIA. I M REQUESTING TO ALL UMMA PLEASE CONCENTRATE IN HOW TO MAKE A KHALIFHA.WHICH IS IMPORTANT WORK TO DO . NOT T O CRITICIZE TO ANY UMMA WHO MAKE THE WORLD CLEAN THANK MAY ALWAYS ALWAYS WITH YOU .PLEASE MAKE DUVA FOR MUSLIMS AND MUSLIMS COUNTRIES TAKE CARE ALLAH HAFIZ
Muhammed Talha Hassan // September 11, 2008 at 9:38 pm |
Assalam-Au-Alaikum
This is the major problem in this Sub-continent.
If one can`t do something he won`t let others do
also.
I would like to say that Deobandi Ulemas should
acknowledge his efforts instead of issuing a Fatwa
against him.
If Deobandi Ulemas are so keen in efforts for
ISlam then why didn`t any DeoBandi/Brelvi ulema
came forward and answered Dr William
Campbell`s book “Quran And Bible In The Light
of Sceince” which spread much mischief and many
muslims became apostates because of that…Noone
was able to answer that book for 8 Years untill
Dr Zakir Naik came forward and shattered his
allegations to pieces….
Wake Up Muslims.
imran // September 12, 2008 at 3:55 pm |
Assalamwailulukum
Dr.Zakir Naik is true legend and please stop dividing Muslim rather try to make them united. No human is perfect beside our beloved prophet MOHAMMED(S.A.W.S). So stop this dirty buissness and try to improve image of islam.kindly forgive if i hanve hurt you.
Ali Affan Yaqoob // September 21, 2008 at 12:05 pm |
As salam o alaikum wa rehmat ULLAHE wa barakatuHU
actually the problem is that whenever any scholar comes up with knowledge and try to prove that QURAN supports science and science supports QURAN, the alim (normally uneducated) who doesnot have any knowledge of science tries to avoid him by issuing fatwas as bhaiyon pait ka sawaal hai agar log sab kuch khud hi perh len ge tau in ko chanda kon de ga in k ghar kaise chalain ge.
the real problem is that today no one himself says Muslim at first stage but this identity has become secondary for him primary identity is sunni,shiya,barelvi,deobandi,salfi,ahlehadith.etc
we should go for unity rather than dispersion.
aur agar alimon ko follow kiya jata rahay ga tau un ki baisedness ka victim ban ker kabhi unity nahi ho paye gi.ALLAH SUBHAN O TAALA hum sab ko Sirat e Mustaqeem p chalayen(Ammeen)
As salam o alaikum
Syed Waqar Hussain // September 25, 2008 at 12:34 am |
ASSALAMUALAIKUM
Mufti Sahib in saying that simple muslim means usual muslims like public.
Yes, we normal muslims have very little knowledge of Islam so before listening any lecture or reading any Islamic books we must know about the scholar nicely.
Dr. Zakir Naik seems to a Ghair Muqallid as he dnt follow any of Four Imams. There are some questions of Ghair Muqallideen which misguide normal muslims, specialy Sunni:
1. Are u Muhammadi or Hanafi?
2. Whome u follow Prophet (saw) or Imam Hanafi?
Let me answer above question:
1. Suppose today is monday and the month is October. Now u answer me Today is October or Monday.
2. Four Imams follow Prophet (saw). The four school of thought started for teaching the Narration of Hadith.
We all know Imam Hanifa is the best Jurist still now.
Actulally Dr.Zakir point himself to better then the great four Jurists(Hanifa, Shafi, Maliki, Hanbali).
Its simple, Naik was and still is a medical doctor and he started researching Islam before couple of years. Then how come some little knowledgeable muslims taking Dr. Zakir as an expert. Dr. Zakir says: ‘I am not an expert. I am just a practicing muslim.’
I request all Last Ummah, please consult with experts. I am also a great fan of Dr.Zakir but I am not Jahil that i will believe whatever he say.
Concerning the matter of Four Imams, please consult with experts. In this topic MashALLAH i have good knowledge. Dr.Naik speech is not right of this topic.
May ALLAH show us all the right path.
JazakALLAH
Syed Waqar Hussain // September 25, 2008 at 12:39 am |
I accept all the challenges of Ghair Muqallideen.
waqar_den@hotmail.com
unknown // September 26, 2008 at 6:48 pm |
Assalam
zakir naik learned from Ahmed Deedat and Ahmed Deedat learned from Izhar ul haq and Izhar ul haq is written by Rahmatullah kairanvi who was a friend and associate of scholars who established darul uloom deoband
1. if u want to know if zakir naik learned from Ahmed deedat works then visit his site and know
2. if y want to know ahmed deedat learned from izhar ul haq then visit his site and know
3. if u want to know who wrote izhar ul haq then search in google
Sumair // October 3, 2008 at 1:01 pm |
The link you have given does not say any thing about Dr.Zakir Naik.
Try to propagate true things only.
————————————————-
Question: 2537 India
I know about why we follow deoband why not bareli shareef plz tell me some reason why?
Answer: 2537 21 Jan, 2008
(Fatwa: 1733/1529=B)
The Deobandis set their beliefs and actions according to the Quran and Hadith. They follow the Sahaba (companions), Tab?een (successors of Sahaba), Imams and pious elders. They shun innovations, un-Islamic customs and traditions, and follow the footsteps of the Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) in each matter. While, the Baralewis are involved in scores of innovations (Bid?aat), superstitions and customs, they are far away from the teachings of the Quran and Hadith. The innovations spread due to ignorance; this is the reason that during the past 50-60 years more than 6 lakh Braalewis have joined the mainstream Muslims (Deobandis) due to blessings of Islamic madarsas and Tableeghi Jamat.
and Allah (Subhana Wa Ta’ala) Knows Best
Darul Ifta, Darul Uloom Deoband
————————————————-
unknown // October 14, 2008 at 11:08 am |
bhai kuch kaam kijye. sirf iktalaf badhane se kaam nahi hoga. lakho muslim kalma-e-tauhid nahi jante. fatwa to bahut door hai
Vicky // October 20, 2008 at 5:06 pm |
Asalam
zakir naik ko bura ya fatwa lagne se pehle ye sun lo naik kabhi ye nahi kehte ke main keh raha hun balke ye kehte hai ke quran kahta hai
aur quran sahi hai.
We shuld folow shafai becoz hanfi jst put his fatwa before rest 3 of imams hanfi havnt writen book on how to do salah
all 4 imams r right
dont engage ur self in fighting 4 imams.Jst pray truly kyunki kis ke ibadat kabul hoge koi nahi janta
takabul mina min nakum
farhan // October 25, 2008 at 6:05 pm |
assalam u alaikum wa rahmatullahe barakatahu
bahut se log kehte hai 4 imam to hai,lekin ibadat kiski kabul hogi koi janta ,beshak allah sab janne wala hai wo ibadat kabul karne wala hai.
mujhe ye bataye ap kis imam ko follow karte hai,ya jahan chale gaye waisi namaz padh li.
ye to bin pende ke lote wali bat ho gayi.jithar jhukao mila udhar jhuk gaye. gaur karo bhai. yun bolne se kuchh nahin hota. sab mohabbat ki bat hai sarkar (S.A..W.A) se.
jiska aqida majboot hai woh janta hai kon sahi kon galat.
allah apko nek taufiq de (AMIN)
khuda hafiz
Noman Haider // October 31, 2008 at 7:00 am |
Assalam
[Hazrat] Ahmed Raza jo khud Deo-Band Madarsay say Taleem Hasil Ker chukay us kay baad unhoo nay
Bareelvi Madarsa open kia tha
As Ali Affan Yaqoob, on September 21st, 2008 at 12:05 pm Said:
bhaiyon pait ka sawaal hai agar log sab kuch khud hi perh len ge tau in ko chanda kon de ga in k ghar kaise chalain ge.
the real problem is that today no one himself says Muslim at first stage but this identity has become secondary for him primary identity is sunni,shiya,barelvi,deobandi,salfi,ahlehadith.etc
we should go for unity rather than dispersion.
He is absolutely right but the thing is that we should consider and read QURAN and AHADITH
Aap khud sochoo aap eek Tree lagatay hoo Mango ka or us ki Gutlian [Seed inside mango] kisi or jaga lagay hoo or waha bhi Mango tree ban jata hay phir us ka mangoo lay ker uss ka Seed kaheen or lagatay hoo to kya woo APPLE niklay gaa obviously wo bhi Mango hi niklay gaa
too meray dostoo ISLAM main Hamaray jo 4 Imam aye un ka matlab ISLAM ko agay barhana tha na kay apas main Dispute peeda kerna tha ………..
Zakir naik is a superb man kyu kay woo sari cheezen QURAN or AHADIS ki roshni say lay ker chalta hay or ager yee Deoband yaa HAREE PAGREE [Green Parrot ] walay ussay ghalat kehtay hain to prove deen yaa phir us say FACE TO FACE Communicate kareen MASAHLLAH ALLAH Toofeeq daynay wala hay
mudasir // November 1, 2008 at 8:39 am |
asalamualaikum
i love zakir naik very much but not for my personal resons but for the sake of allah subhanawatalah regarding the conroversy of yazid this is bit illogical to find the place in our minds what would have happened since 1400.years ago. futher more it is of history type not of hadith which can be checked for its athuenticity there are fatWAS OF IMMAM GHAZALI AND ALAMA IBN TAYYIMIYA IBN KATHIR AND MOLA ALI QARI AND VARIOUS OTHERS WHO SAID WE CANT CURSE YAZID .SO DR.NAIK DIDNOT SIAD OF HIMSELF BUT QOUTED FROM THE ATHORITES.
Mohammed Jalal // November 7, 2008 at 10:47 am |
assalam alykum rehmatullahi wabarkatuh every body.
don’t blame any muslim or dr. zakir naik coz quran says. allah ki rassi ko mazbuti se thaamlo
what is rassi quran & sahin hadith we should follow quran & sahin Hadith. not barelvi, not devbound , not ahele hadith not tabliqhi jamat we should not divide in this things
WE ARE MUSLIMS FOLLOW
(ALLAH & RASOOL (SAW)
ALLAH EK HAI , RASOOL EK HAI , QURAN EK HAI , MUSLIM BHI SAB EK HAI. AMEEN
Assalamu Alaikum // November 7, 2008 at 2:21 pm |
We love Dr.Zakir Naik…very very much….He is a person of knowledge not like these deobandis.so called muslims..they even dont know the essence of islam..shame on deobandis..
javed // November 7, 2008 at 2:26 pm |
thses mad mullas are **** and this is regular practice of mullas since the biginning of deovband. there act can not tarnish the image of great zakir naik. these mullas always being used by a anti peace and justice community. they always think that only they are sole representative of islam and muslin though nobody has chosen them.i think this should be stope immdieately otherwise muslim would beat these mullas on road.
Note-Use Civil language next time who ever it May be.Control ur emotions
inam // November 8, 2008 at 1:54 pm |
Ek Khuda Ek KAABA hai Quraan Ek
Kalimai Haq se Apni hai pechcaan Ek
Khatimul anbiyaa apne sardar hai
Kaise mumkin hai phir hum bikhar jaiyenge…….
My dear muslim brothers dont get carried away by the word of the so called maulvis who dont support there claim with supporting Quran and hadith there days are numbered ….
Ab inki dukaan band hone wali hai isliye beechare pareshan hai… gaye woh din jab log andhe ban kar inke peeche chalte the ab hum inse puchte hai laao daleel agar tum sacche ho
inam // November 8, 2008 at 1:57 pm |
I love Dr Zakir Naik for his excellent way of representing Islam … yeh so called fatwa dene wale kya soorahe the jab log Islam pe ungli utha rehe the… agar himmath hai toh William campbell aur Sri Ravi shankar aur un jaise logon se debate kar ke dikhao ….
mudasir // November 8, 2008 at 3:50 pm |
FOR ALLAH,S SAKE SPARE A NOBLE PERSON WHO HAS SPENT WHOLE OF HIS LIFE N INTELLIGENTIA IN SPREADING THE MESSAGE OF ISLAM, WHO CLEARED MOST OF MISCONCEPTIONS AGAINST ISLAM WORLD OVER, WHO HS PERSUADED SO MANY PEOPLE 2 CNVRT 2 THE TRUE RELIGION…PLZ SPARE DR. NAIK …DONT USE HIM AS AN AGEMDA 2 RELISE UR MATERIAL GAINS…LET HIM DO HIS WORK….
Peace // November 8, 2008 at 9:04 pm |
Salam-o-Rehma,
Dear Muslim brothers,
Please refrain from abusing any of the Scholars. Both the Fatwa-issuing scholar, and Zakir Naik are scholars, and you cannot be disrespectful to them.
Actually, there seems to be a misunderstanding by the fatwa-ssiuing scholar, and hence he gave the fatwa.
I hope that he will realsie his mistake, atleast after listening to Zakir Naik’s clarification.
Misunderstanding do happen, but this should not make us to abuse our own BROTHERS.
May Allah have his mercy on all of us. Aameen
zulqarnain // November 9, 2008 at 11:33 am |
asalam-o-alaikum brothers&sisters reader,
i am also big fan of Dr.Zakir . but i had remember ealier life ahmedi firqa leader. i would like to share that details with you all. and watch carefull every top person’s action. i dont say that Dr. Zakir will do same mirza ghulam did. Allah(SWT) save him from all bad.
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was born at dawn on Friday February 13, 1835 CE in Qadian, Punjab, India the surviving child of twins born to an affluent family. As a child, he received his early education at home. He learned to read the Arabic text of the Qur’an and studied basic Arabic Grammar and the Persian language. In addition, he also studied some works on medicine from his father, Mirza Ghulam Murtaza who was a physician.
Around the age of sixteen or seventeen he also started studying Christianity. Particularly the Christian missionary arguments against Islam. During this period he is said to have collected some three thousand articles critical of Islam and set out to reply to them. This culminated in his book entitled Baraheen-e-Ahmadiyya, which earned him some fame and respect among the Muslim scholars.
From 1864 to 1868, Upon his father’s wishes, he worked as a clerk in Sialkot where he is said to have come in contact with Christian missionaries with whom he would have conversations on religion. After 1868 he returned to Qadian, as per his father’s wishes, where he was entrusted to look after some estate affairs. During all this time Ahmad was known as a social recluse because he would spend most of his time in seclusion studying religious books and praying in the local Mosque. As time passed, he began to engage more with the Christian missionaries and would often confront them in public debates. Particularly in defending Islam against their criticism; especially with the Christian missionaries based in the town of Batala, about 11 miles (18 km) from Qadian in India.
Rahman K // November 9, 2008 at 7:20 pm |
I think at the present time there is no person like Dr Zakir Naik who has got so much knowledge in Islam as well as Hinduism and Christiniaty /Judaism. He knows Quran more than other Islamic scholar, Geeta/Bedh more than Hindu scholar , bible more than protestant/catholic scholar. He refers verses from all the religious books like anything which the individal scolars from that religion even do not know.
He is a man of peace and wants to show the world what Islam is.
Whenever I hear his speech I only think Allah has given him something special which most of us do not have.
May Allah help him in spreading the true meaning of Islam through out the world.
He should ignore all the fatwas against him.
M.Raashid jeelani // November 10, 2008 at 4:10 am |
Dr. Naik acknowledge’s people according to Qura’an & Sahih Ahadith, he has not his own story, he has enlightened the whole world which was kept in dark by these deoband & barelvi mullas (ullama-e-suu).
stop doing this or you will lament.
aubid // November 10, 2008 at 6:42 am |
the Deobandi people can give any fatwa on any thing on behalf of Indian people and to please Hindu people. but we should accept also fatwa which are in accordance to SHARIAH.
Faisal Ahmed // November 11, 2008 at 1:50 pm |
ASSALAMALIKUM. here Dr. zakir naik right in this issue, because it not compusalry to fallow any imam. because Allah’s Messanger said , falow the quraan and hadees . if imam’s masala prooved in hadees or quraan then no problem but if he say against the quraan or hadees then his word rejected.
Faisal Ahmed // November 11, 2008 at 1:52 pm |
hum par qurran wo sunnath par amal kar na zaruri hai agar kisi ko is bae me ziyada jan kari chaheye ya wo is bath pe kuch kah na chata hai to plz mail me this id- faiz024@gmail.com
Sunny Dhar // November 12, 2008 at 10:02 am |
Asalamalaykum Everybody,
Ordering a fatwa against Zakir Nayak is a worst act in todays chapter.Understanding Zakir nayak Is a big thing & it needs a special mind.The logic he produces is a Gift which he has got from Allah(swt)…If he says we shoul worship Allah only..He is nowhere wrong.Worshiping anyone except Allah is a shirk, as we cant associate partners with him..Prophet Mohammad(saw) was Allah’s Beloved & apostople.We should have high respectfor him(PBUH).But we cant worship him that will be a big sin…Also the methodology which Zakir has addopted is universal & most fitting ..U need to be intellectual enough to understand his logic & wy of Dawaah to nonmuslims/infidels.One who will order ban on him will get a definite torment from Allah(swt).U need to be a muslim.No need to attach any tag with your identity..Zakir has a faboulous reputation today among all community as he has a dare to tell the truth to illogical theories of non muslims/infidels..I salute his approach through the book ‘Concept of God in Major Religions”.it is really an admirable effort..Please dont interrupt him & other scholars,.Those who are implementing ban on zakir Nayak are fools & without Knowledge…Islam is a complete monothetic Religion(Deen) & there is n othwer altenative to save yourself on judgement day as Allah(swt) clearly allarms everybody in Quran.(chapter 3,verse 85.Al-Imran).A peron who desires a religion other than Islam(SUBMISSION TO ALLAH), it wont be accepted of him/her & in hereafter he/she will be among the loosers………….So we need to warn everybody in this world about this touchstone……..
Let Zakir Nayak do his duty & please dont inteerupt him as you are proving urself without knowledge which is not required………
Thanks
Khuda Hafiz….
Kamran Khan // November 13, 2008 at 5:22 am |
Assalamu Alaikum,
I good to see that most of the people almost all speaking in fever of Dr. Zakir Naik,
because according to hadith of prophet (s.a.w.), momin ka dil sahi fatwa deta hai.
that’s why majority are supporting Dr.Zakir Naik…
jin ki wajah se Muslim aur Islam ka sahi meaning aaj bahut sey log jantey hai
unhi ko non Muslim ka fatwa deena sahi hai kya??? Dr. Zakir Naik ek sachey daee hai…
wo kabhi bhi kisi organization ya jamaat kay against nahi kahtey… unho ney kaha hamey ek dusrey
ko support karna chahiye. wo four Imaam & sabhi Ulma ki izzat kartey hai… we are not sunni,
deobandi, tabligi or barelwi …we are muslims, one ummatey muslima….Because of his outstanding lecture , i realize that
giving dawa to non Muslims is so important for every muslims..he quote the holy Quran with references in
front of non muslim.. Which is the correct way of spreading the teaching of Islam and Allah kalams….may Allah give us
intention to spread the massage of Islam and may peace,mercy & blessing of Allah (s.w.t) be upon all daees of islam..
MUSLIM // November 13, 2008 at 9:37 am |
Assalam o alaikum,
Can any one help me out to find, where is the fatwa given by Depband, as i went through the link but couldn’t find???
Gahlot // November 13, 2008 at 3:14 pm |
assalam alykum rehmatullahi wabarkatuh every body
Dr. Zakir Naik is one of daee of Islam who intention to correct misconcptions about Islam according the Qur’an.One massage first of all we are muslim.
May Allah have his mercy on all of us. Aameen
Mohsin Sayyed (Pune) // November 14, 2008 at 12:04 am |
ASAK
The bottom line is that “YOUNG PEOPLE LISTEN TO DR. ZAKIR, THEY LIKE HIM” the reason behind that Dr. Zakir Naik is proving Islam with the help of Quran’s SIGNS & today’s SCIENCE the way today educated people understands whether muslim or non muslim with interactive communication.
Have you ever experienced a single person who has come up with these Fatwa functioning in such an innovative and revolutionary fashion?
I want to ask few questions to the people who have launched a Fatwa against him that:
I appreciate that you have deep theoretical knowledge, BUT can you prove your knowledge with the relativity of points below?
* Do you have knowledge of Science & Technology?
* Do you have knowledge of History?
* Do you have knowledge of Duniya?
* Do you have knowledge of Current Political affairs and crises?
* Do you have knowledge of who is writing what and who is finger-pointing towards Islaam?
* Do you practice DEEN & DUNIYA at same time? Moreover do you remember all this?
* Then go achieve all this and then think about issuing Fatwa and don’t do oil-poil of any small thing which your brain does not digest. And for the sake of Allah(s.w.t) do not split “UNITED MUSALMAAN”
I strongly condemn any Fatwa against Dr. Zakir Naik, go through entire web page and you will see this is the voice of “ONE MUSALMAAN”
I am sorry to say but I can’t stop myself as one brother wrote above that Agar Zakir Naik Jawaa Dilonpar Chhaa Gaya To Inlogonko Apni “Dukaan Band Karni Padegi”
(Allah tamam insaniyat ko nek hidayat de Aamin)
Allah Hafiz
kr. amir khusro // November 14, 2008 at 5:39 am |
Assalamwalaykum
mein ek baat kahan chaunga “Aaj mujhe jo thodi samajhe islam ke baare mein hai wo Dr. Zakir Naik ki wajah se hai otherwise mere khud ke bahut saare sawaalon ke jawab dene mein ye murge, bakre khaane waale maulana nehin dete they-kabhi jawab diye bhi to wo mere upar se nikal gaye” Dr. Zakir Naik jaisi shaksiyat ki jab zabaan hilti hai to muslim to muslim jo gair muslim log hein unke dilon dimaag mein aisa zalajala aata hai ki dimaag ki saari gandagi nikal jaati hai aur islam ki asal maloomaat hoti hai. Even mujhe to lagata hai ki unhonein muslmaano ki dukhti nas per behtreen malham lagaya hai unhein humko zabaan di hai samajhe di hai apne ek alag scientifc style se quran ko samjhaya hai.
Mein in sabhi fatwah dene waale maulanao se kahonga ki free ke murge, bakre khaane kam karo, fatwah ka business or politics band karo aur Dr. Zakir naik ki tarah mahanat karo aur unke jaisa bane ki koshish karo.
allaha aapko akal de
khuda hafiz
Bilal // November 14, 2008 at 5:40 am |
A person becomes a Muslim by having good Beilefs like Allah is1 and all His Messengers were a source of benefit to humanity.but 1 becomes a momin by having good aqaid and amaal like which go on to show the love a person has for Prohet Muhammad(S.A.W.W) and all the AwliaAllah and not which show the love one has for the people who were the enemies of Aal-e-Rasul(S.A.W.W) like yazeed.and the movement headed by Dr Zakir has been in the process of doing such amaal that show their love for specially yazeed.
aur Allah k dost wohi hain jo Allah aur us k naik bando ko pasand kare na k woh jo un se lagao rakhe jo Allah k yarun se dushmani kare.
Bilal // November 14, 2008 at 5:50 am |
Hamari ,Ahlesunnat ke nazar main acha insan woh nahi k jo zayda ilm rakhe balke woh hai jo zayda ilm rakhe aur ussi ke maddad se Allah aur us k doston ke muhabbat logon k dilon tak aam kare.
Dr zakir ne baray hi achay kam kiye pr ap iss ke jamat ke ganday aqaid bhe to dekhain.AGAR SIRF AIK NAIKI JANNAT LE JA SAKTI HAI TO SIRF AIk HI GANDA AMAL DOSAKH BHE LE JA SAKTA HAI.
Dr Zakir ke dars ka asar tou ap sab dekh hi rahay hain k jo sar se paun tak Nabi(S.A.W.W) ke sunnatain sajae usse ye log green parrot kehte hain
Bilal // November 14, 2008 at 6:01 am |
Tableegh kr k logon ko musalman bana dena boht bari baat hai pr sab kam tab kharab ho jata hai jab ap usse ye chez sikha dain k DushmananeIslam ki izzat karo.
Yazeed 5 ya ghaliban 7 chezon ke wajha se ghalt insan kelaya gya jin main se kuch ye hain.
1)wo be namazi tha(2)wo sharabi tha(3)wo zina karta tha(4)wo janwarun(animals)ke larai karata tha(5)wo nach gane ka shokeen tha
Bilal // November 14, 2008 at 6:29 am |
Islam tabbiat ka nam nahi Islam shariat ka nam hai aur shariat kehte hai un se dushmani karo jo Allah k dushman hain na k hum unko woh aizaz dena shuru kr dain jo Sihaba ya naik bando ko dia jata hai
think urslf that if a person does a good speech u start liking him without thinking what feelings he has 4 evildoers and what are his views 4 those that have been source of discomfort for specially ImamHassan(R.A)
DR.C.L.ABDUL RAHIMAN // November 14, 2008 at 4:14 pm |
ASSALAMU ALAIKUM
WHY SO CALLED SUNNY GROUPS IS AGAINST DR.ZAKIR NAIK.. HE IS A GREAT INTELLECTUAL OF THIS CENTURY. ALLAH HAS BLESSED HIM WITH ENORMOUS MEMORY. HE IS WALKING ENCYCLOPEDIA..MANY HAVE EMBRACED ISLAM BECAUSE OF HIM.DONT CRITCISE HIM.MANY OF THE DURGAWALLAS MAY NOT LIKE HIM. THE DHARGAWALLAS WANT TO EXPLOIT ILLITERATE MUSLIM MASSES AND TAKE AWAY HIS MONEY AND EEMAN AND SEND HIM TO HELL AND HELPING SHYTAAN..
Arsalaan // November 14, 2008 at 4:49 pm |
As salam alaikum wr wb,
I would like to remind you that Dr.Zakir Naik is a daee of Islam.He is the best international scholar on the face of the earth.He is spreading the true teachings of Allah(swt) & Mohammed(saws) to the world.Alhamdulillah many non-muslims are accepting Islam.Giving a fatwa will not harm his cause because Allah(swt) is with him.
May Allah have mercy on him.
Ameeen.
MUSLIM // November 15, 2008 at 5:51 am |
Assalam O Alaikum to all Muslims.
We should respect and support Dr. Zakir Naik.
irfan mansuri // November 15, 2008 at 9:59 am |
i read all above articles most of people support jakir naik and abused to athers (mostly deoband) . I think all people who abused deoband they dont have any knowledge about deoband or islam they just listene lectures of jakir naik and they think that it is sufficient for us or our akhirat but they are wrong alim (mukka) is very important in muslims life to see what is wrong and what is right but some doul people doesnt know that ,they think we are educated ,we are very forward but actually they are in darkness . inshaallh allah will show him right way . Finally if we talk about Deoband or Tabligh Jamaat many alims is there they have more knowledge about islam then jakir naik and more educated than jakir naik . I am not a against of jakir naik but only one thing which i dont like that is jakir nike doesnt belive on any muslek he indirectly says all musleks are Gumrah but i believe on all muslek
Syed Shabbir Ahmed // November 16, 2008 at 6:51 am |
Assalamu Alaikum Rahmath ulla hi Barka tu ……..
I had complete study of all the four Immams and their life history no where they have ask the community to follow them,but instead they said throw our words on the wall & follow Prophet Mohammed SAS if u find our words conflits in any sort with Prophet Mohammed …Infact they are very great peoples & good Muslims they followed prophet mohammed 100% . For ur information this 4 Immam policy was started 200years after the death of all the 4 Immams.
Further all these fatwa’s political Baised ……..
Can I ask a Question to all these people ….who are raising finger against Zakir Naik
What kind of ISLAM their are Promoting ……….Is it Islam of Prophet Mohamed or ISLAM of their own choice …………….Read Quran or listen Quran ……..Now available in all the langauges in all the forms and understand u will not find any other book much clear & easy……Syed Shabbir Ahmed
mohammad habeebuddin // November 16, 2008 at 8:17 am |
Dear Friends
salamoalekum
We as a general muslim, having not much knwoledge should not involve in any sought of such discussion. Ulema and their Ilmeyat is supreme in the lilght Quran & Hadith. Catch hold of someone who teach you the practical aspects of islam, unless othewise they are very much different. Now the world is running with lot of things, which were already narrated & alarmed by our Prophet(p.b.u.h). Be aware of the great enemy Shaitan, who always try to bring some contraversies and he target the ulema first. May allah save all of us with his tricks (ameen).
MUSLIM // November 17, 2008 at 6:34 am |
Brother Bilala, Assalam O Alaikum,
Jo log bhi Dr. Zakir Naik ko nafrat karte hai, main un ko achi tarah janta hoo,
Ye woo log hai, jo bahut didno se kuch is trah ki baton ka intjar kar rahre the.
Ye woo log hai, jo Yazid ke issue se pahle se, Dr. Zakir Naik ko pasant nahi karte.
App se meri aik request hai,
Kia app Yazid or Karbala ki Jung ke bare main apni ray dengey?
Karbala, ke larai ki asal wajah kia thi?
****Agar ho sake to, English me answer de.
wiq! // November 17, 2008 at 11:15 am |
salam!
i don’t know when we will realize our duties? Allah simply stop us to divide Islam in caste and beliefs.. But no since birth i am watching these stuff around me. And you know this only happens in this sub continent…..
And same people when leave to abroad they take food together they live together no issue about any cast and beliefs.
I think there must be law to punish who play this game…
DR.C.L.RAHMAN // November 19, 2008 at 7:23 pm |
SALAAM,
WE ALL SHOULD PRAY TO ALLAH ALONE. WE SHOULD NOT PRAY TO ANYONE IN THE KHABAR.
SHAH AHMAD HASHMI // November 28, 2008 at 4:38 pm |
salam to all MUSLIMS.
i have studied the stupid try of [[[[Muhammed Talha Hassan, on September 11th, 2008 at 9:38 pm Said:
This is the major problem in........Dr Zakir Naik came forward........ Wake Up Muslims.]]]
HE IS ABSOLUTELY WRONG IN ANSWERING.
1ST OF ALL , IS THERE ONLY ONE BOOK RITTEN BY NON-MUSLIMS, AGAINST OUR ISLAM?
OR THE BOOK OF
Dr William Campbell “Quran And Bible In The Light
of Sceince” HAVE MORE IMPORTANCE?
WHY DID HE TRY TO ANSWER ONLY HIS BOOK? & NOT OF OTHERS?
IS THIS COMPULSURY TO ANSWER ALL BOOKS WRITTEN BY NON-MUSLIMS?
WHY OUR ULAMA WASTE THEIR MORE IMPORTANT TIME FOR THOSE BOOKS WHO R MEANINGLESS FOR MUSLIMS?
IS THERE ANY MUSLIM WHO IS IMPRESED BY THOSE BOOK?
NOT AT ALL.
OR IS THERE ANY NON MUSLIM BECAME MUSLIM?
IF ANY ONE HAS BECOME THEN HE IS NOT MUSLIM ACCORDING TO U .
BECOZ HE HAD BECOME MUSLIM AFTER OBEYING [TAQLEED ] DR. ZAKIR.
& ACCORDING TO U “TAQLEED KARNY WALA MUSHRIK HAI”
SO WHAT DO U SAY?
2ND IS THERE ANY BENIFIT OF HIS ANSWERING AGAINST THAT BOOK?
YOU PEOPLE SAY THAT [TAQLEED] {TO OBEY} IS NA-JAIZ & WE OUGHT NOT TO BE HANAFI’ SHAFAI’ MALAKI’ ETC.
I ASK , IF U DO NOT OBEY ANY OTHER, EXEPT ALLAH AND HOLY PROPHIT, THEN
WITHOUT OBEYING {TAQLEED} YOUR PARENTS,
HOW CAN YOU PROVE THAT U R SONS/DAUGHTERS OF YOUR PARENTS, TO WHOM U CALL YOUR PARENTS.
HERE U ARE OBEYING UR PARENTS, IT IS TOHEED, IF WE OBEY SAHABA IKRAM TABAEEN IKRAM TABA TABAEEN THEN WE, HOW CAN BE MUSHRIK?
FINALLY I SAY THAT THINK WELL BEFORE SAYING.
DR. ZAKER IS MISGUAIDING OUR SIMPLE MUSLIMS, WHO HAVE NOT MUCH KNOWLEDGE OF ISLAM.
SIMPLY WE CAN SAY HIM AGENT OF NON-ISLAMIC [ GHAIR MUQALID] PEOPLE.
FINALLY I PRAY , AA ALLAH PLEASE HELP US & PROTECT OUR IMAAN? AMEN.
FROM
SHAH AHMAD HASHMI
LAHORE PAKISTAN.
SHAH AHMAD HASHMI // November 28, 2008 at 4:51 pm |
SALAM TO ALL MUSLIMS.
I HAV STUDIED
{{{{{{{Moinuddin Pathan Ahmedabad, on July 14th, 2008 at 12:57 pm Said:
The Deobandhi people has nothing to do
that’s y they have open a factory of Fatwa
}}}}
I M SUNNI HANAFI BRELVI.
I M NOT DEOBANDI.
BUT I ANSWER OYU.
MY ANSWER IS THAT OOOOOO CHEAP
MOIN PATHAN? HAVE U MIND IN UR BRAIN?
ACCORDING TO YOU “The Deobandhi people has nothing to do
that’s y they have open a factory of Fatwa ”
OOOO CHEAP PATHANN … YOU HAVE NOTHING TO DO.
SO YOU HAVE MADE A LITTLE SHOPE OF WORDS AGAINST ULAMA IKRAM?
U OUGHT TO DO SOMETHING ELSE?
KABI AKAILY BEETH K SOOCHNA?
AUR KHUDA SY PUCHNA K JAB KHUDA NE DMAGH BANTA TO TUMHEN KIA KAM MILA THA YA TUM KO ISKA ISTEMAAL NHI BTAYA GAYA?
SHAH AHMAD HASHMI // November 28, 2008 at 5:19 pm |
SALAM TO ALL MUSLIMS.
I CHALLANGE TO ALL GHAIR MUQALADEENS.
ON THE TOPICS OF
1
TAQLEED { WO BE TAQLEED KARTY HEN}
2
HELP {MADAD} [WO B MADAD MANGTY HEN]
3
SHIRK [ APNI TAHREERON K MUTABIK WOHI
LOG MUSHRIK HEN]
4
ILAM-E-NABI
APNI TAHREERO K MUTABIQ WO B ILAM-E-GHAIB MANTY HEN
5
GHAYARVEN SHAREEF
WO B GHAYARVEN K KHATAM MEIN SHAMIL HOTY HEN AUR WAHAN JA K KHATAM PARHTY B HEN
6
DATA DARBAR HAZRI
WO B DATA DARBAR KUCH NA KUCH HASIL KARNY KI NIYAT SE JATY HEN [ CHAHY DATA SAHIB K MIZAR PE LANGAR HI HASIL KARNY KI GHARAZ SE JATY HEN MGAR JAYE BINA UNKI BANN NHI PATI]
ISS K ILAWA
MAIN CHALLANGE KARTA HOON K
KOI GHAIR MUQALID MERAY KUCH SAWALAAT K JWABAT DY DY JO MAIN NE KAI HAWABIYON SE PUCHY HEN.
ap k mutabiq allah k siwa kisi aur se mango to shirk hai.
am i right?
ham sunni log Allah k sath sath Anbiya ikram se sahaba ikram se tabaeen ikram taba tabaeen ikram se aouliaa ikram se bal-k tamam musliman logon se mangty hen mgar isko shirak nhi samajhty.
isi waja se ap hawabi GHAIR MUQALID log ham sunni logon ko mushrik samajhty ho.
Dekho agar tum apney father sey paisey mango, to tum usay [apny baap ko] kiya samajho/kaho gay/?
jawab do?
SAMPLE
QUESTION NO 1:
Mera ap se sawaal yeh hai k agar koi shakhash kisi bat ko shirak na samjhy aur wo kam kary b to kia wo mushrik ho jata hai k nhi hota?
QUESTION NO 2:
Agar koi shakhash kisi bat ko shirak b samjhy aur wo kam kary bii to kia wo khud b mushrik ho jata hai k wo mushrik nhi hota?
QUESTION NO 3:
ham sunni log auliya ikram se mangty hen mgar unko khuda nhi smajhty. kia siraf mangny se ham log mushrik ho gaye?
QUESTION NO 4:
kia siraf maang lo to iska matlab k ham ne Anbiya/aouliya ikram ko Khuda maan liya aur ham log mushrik ho gaye?
QUESTION NO 5:
to phir ap log har ik shehar k har mash-hoor muqamaat pe imdadi camps laga k qun mang rahy ho?
QUESTION NO 6:
kia ap janty ho k ap k apny camps k irad girad banars pe likha hota hai k { APNY KASHMEERI BHAION KI MADAD KRO}? [ nhi yaqeen to muridke city ja k main bazar k saameny dekh lo k Lashkar tayeba walon ne likha hai k APNY KASHMEERI BHAION KI MADAD KARO] kia wo b mushrik ho gaye ya wo pakky taouheedi hain?
QUESTION NO 7:
kia ap k mutabiq un logon ne ham ko bal-k sab logon ko sunni/shiya/hwabi/chatrralvi/deibandi aur deegar bal-k ghair muslim logon se madad mang k un sab ko KHUDA manna k nhi?
QUESTION NO 8:
kia saoudi arab mein hakoomat hwabiyon ki hai ya kisi aur ki? kia un hwabi logon ne USA [amarica] se madad mangi k nhi?
kia amarican fooj ko control diya hai k nhi? kia saoudia ko amarica madad dy raha hai k nhi?
QUESTION NO 9:
kia saoudia ne ab pakistan ko kaha hai k ham ap ko oil [tail] de k pakistan ki economy mazboot karny mein madad deen gy?
QUESTION NO 10:
kia phir ap inn sab logon ko b mushrik kehty ho? ya k siraf sunni kehlwany walon ko hi mushrik kaho gy?
AP MUJHY INN 10 SAWALAAT K JAWABAT DO TO MAIN MAAN JAOUN GA K AP APNY AQEEDA PE PAKKY HO. AGAR AP NE JAWABAAT NA DIYE TO MAIN SAMJHON GA K AP KO DEEN KA KUCH PATA NHI . BUS AP NE YEHI JANA HAI K SIRAF SUNNI KEHLOUANY WALY KO MUSHRIK KAHO.
MAIN AP KO [1ST JAN 2009 ] 1ST DAY OF NEW YEAR 2009. TAK KA TIME DAETA HOON. APNY KISI AALIM SE PUCH K MUJHY INN 10 SAWALAAT K JWABAT DO AUR MUJHY MUTMAEN KARO. YA MAAN JAO K HAM SUNNI LOG HAQQ PE HEN?
JWABAAT ZROOR DEANA?
YA MUJHY MUTMAEN KAR K APNY SAATH MILA LO YA TUM B HAMARY SAATH HO CHALO.
AUR SHAYED TUM JAANTY HO K FATAH SIRAF HAQ KI HOTI HAI.[ INSHA-ALLAH ]
YOUR WELLWISHER
SHAH AHMAD HASHMI.
CITY , LAHORE, PAKISTAN.
E-MAIL ymhsah@yahoo.com
answerssss mail zror karna?
Ayaz // December 13, 2008 at 7:57 pm |
Dear Mohammad TALHA,
U are correct.I agree with u
Shoaib // December 15, 2008 at 6:36 am |
Assalamo Alaikum to all
islaah jaruri hai.
naveed // December 15, 2008 at 11:28 pm |
dear brother what we can get the complete information about dr zakir
MUSLIM // December 17, 2008 at 11:11 am |
Bother Shah Ahmed Hasmi,…………… Assalam O Alaikum.
Brother, what you asked is not a 10 numbers of question, but it is only one.
Which is, “can we ask help from other then Allah SWT”?
The answer is so simple that you don’t have to be a great Alim or Scholar of Islam.
Only thing is, you have to have some basic knowledge of Islam and common sense.
Let me make you understand.
**** Let us say, you are in your house and feeling hungry.
WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO NOW?
Of course, you will call someone from you family with food.
WHY will you call to someone from your family?, because they are present with you alive in physical from, which is not forbidden in Islam at all.
Hereby you will never call Allah SWT to come WITH FOOD and feed.
**** Let us say, you don’t have anything to eat, and you are so hungry that you feel like dying and also you and your family can’t go out of your house due to some reason.
WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO NOW?
Here you need someone to help you REMOTELY.
Tell me brother, being a Muslim, WHO will come in your mind????????????
Now, In view of your own post, I feel you have two options. (For me it is only one, ALLAH SWT).
Option #1. Calling Allah SWT for help.
Option #2. Calling someone other than Allah SWT for help.(naus billah)
If you will select OPTION # 1, then no problem, you are true Muslim.
If you select OPTION # 2, then it will be proved that you have TWO believes in your mind AND BOTH ARE AGAINST THE TEACHING OF ISLAM.
1) You DON”T believe that Allah SWT is present every ware, He SWT is aware of every thing, He SWT can listen you.
2) If you believe Allah SWT is present, but still calling someone else, then it is the disrespect to Allah SWT.
How can you think that? ……….
Someone else can be more nearer than Allah SWT.
Someone else can be more aware than Allah SWT.
Someone else can listen more than Allah SWT.
Someone else can be more helpful and merciful than Allah SWT.
Someone else does have full time attention to you but Allah SWT doesn’t.
I mean the point is, there is not a single reason to call other than Allah SWT.
Some people say, “even though we believe that Allah SWT is present every ware, some times we look for wasila (link) of pious people or Aulia Ikram etc., so that our call can be listen, or will be more effective, etc., considering own self as sinner.
This is again nonsense act in a sense that……
If you think, Allah SWT will not listen because you are sinner, then even an Auliya will go as mediator then also Allah will come to know that this Aulia came for a sinner.
And what about this Aulia?, who is supporting a sinner, who is mediating for a sinner.
Hence, again in any point of view, there is not a single reason to call other than Allah SWT.
Allah SWT knows the best.
imran // December 22, 2008 at 9:32 am |
Assalamu alaikum.
BISMILLAHIR RAHMANIR RAHEEM
Muslim on Dec 17th 2008 at 11:11am said is right.. Whatever u need help just ask allah whether u r a sinner or not… Allah listens to everyone he also knows everything whatever u is in ur heart….
About Dr. zakir naik i like him because he is a daa’e…
and i go for jamaat 40days, 3days, 4monys etc..
aur muje abi tak jamaat kaha gaya ho ki hum debandi hai ya tableeg jammat awle hai halanki hame ye kaha gaya hai ki hamare yaha koi jamaat nahi dawaath ka kaam har ek musalmaan ko karna hai jaise zakir naik ne bhi kaha tha
aur mera khayal hai ki haq ki dawaath kisi bhi tarah karo… woh daa’ee hai lekin usme shirk aur bidaath na ho..
jisne bhi dr. naik ke bare me fatwe jari kiye ho chahe woh barelwi ho, debaandi ho, alehadith ho main unse raazi nahi ho…
Allah sabse behter janne wala hai…
may Allah giude us the straiht path.. maeen..
Sarah // December 24, 2008 at 11:42 am |
zakir naik spreads hate speech.
http://letusbuildpakistan.blogspot.com/2008/11/mumbai-attacks-urban-jihadis-and-role.html
MUSLIM // December 27, 2008 at 7:14 am |
Mr/MRS. Sarah, are you muslim?????
Hussain // January 24, 2009 at 6:56 pm |
Asalamalaykum
we are just fighting and showing our weakness to non muslims. Zakir naik is explaining to non muslims about islam so for they explaination he uses some words which are not being accepted by the lovers of prophet (pbuh). In the above reply given by Mr.Muslim that “Hereby you will never call Allah SWT to come WITH FOOD and feed” you shall know that allah only feed us all the time weather it may be direct or indirect.
I am just absorbing the indications of qayamath and request all the muslim brothers to pray for each other and follow the true path of islam and sunnah of Prophet mohamed (Pbuh).
We need unity not Division when the time of help or war against islam comes we must be muslim not Sunni, Wahabi, Deobandi please wake up by seeing the war in Iraq, Gaza allah has protected indian muslims from all this so just be a muslim.
We can not forget the Khidmat of great Sahaba, Ahle Bath, and saints but we should be in limit while paying respect to them.
I am with celebrating of Milad Un Nabi as it shall be a day of happiness we allah gifts you some thing and prophet (saws) is a great gift to all muslims and muslim should have this happiness from his heart you think by your self about this and see you feel happy or not. I am not qouting and hadeeth as i want some thing to think by our self.
Lastly praying for all muslims all over the world.
assalamalaykum
Zubair // January 25, 2009 at 1:46 am |
Zakir Naik ……..A man in Coat, tie and pant……….teaching Islam……is he trying to show modern islamic picture? Why not he put cross on his neck……..Christian suit with Islamic teaching.
Mohammad Danish // January 26, 2009 at 2:25 pm |
Afsos hota hai dekh kar ‘Lailahaillalah Mohammad Rasoollallah’ padhne waalon ko kyo k ye inka matlab nahi jaante aur khud ko Musalman kehte hai. Tum Kabar par chaadar bhi chadaate ho aur Lailahaillalah k naare bhi buland karte ho, tum Murdo ko bhi pukarte ho aur Lailahaillalah ki awaz ko bhi buland karte ho, tum murdo se darte ho phir bhi Lailahaillalah padhte ho, tumhare andar murdo ki mohabbat zyada hai phir bhi tum Lailahaillalah par bahas karte ho….MUJHE SIRF EK SAWAAL KA JAWAAB DE DO BAS! MUSHRIKIN MAKKAH IMAM-E-AZAM SALLALAHOALAIHE WASLAM K ZAMMANE MAI KYA KARTEY THEY JIS PAR ALLAH NE UNHE KAAFIR AUR MUSHRIK KAHA JAB K WO IBRAHIM(A.S) JAISE SHAKSIYAT KO MAANTE THEY?? ISKA JAWAAB MAI DUNGA AGLE POST ME INSHALLAH AL-FURQAN K HAWALE SE.
NOTE—- YAAD RAHE MUSHRIKIN MAKKAH ALLAH KO MANTE THEY, YE QURAN KAHTA HAI MAI NAHI… ANSWER PLZ.
Mohammad Danish // January 26, 2009 at 2:43 pm |
Doosra haadsa aaj k musalmano k saath ye hua k wo kalma Risaalat ko bhi nahi samje!! ye kalma Allah subhan’taala hame isliye padhne bol rahe kyo k ye Gawahi hai Rasool(s.a.w) k tableeg ko accept karne ka..
OI 4 IMAM K MOHABBAT ME PAAGLON!! ALLAH TO SIRF APNI NABI KI BAAT KI GUARANTEE LE RAHA HAI IS KALMA K ZARYE, TUMHARE IMAM KI ISNADH KYA HAI, TUMHARE KI GUARANTEE KYA HAI, Nabi jo kehte hai wo Allah ka hukm hota hai, unki baath mai nafsi khwahish nahi hota, majboori nahi hota aur galti se kahin par galti ho bhi jaye(dalil maujud hai) to turant Wahi-e-ilahi use rectify karta hai KYA TUMHARE IMAM K SAATH BHI YAHI WAAKYA HAI? TO PHIR TUMHE ‘Lailahaillalah ImamRasoolAllah(Astaghfirulla)’ padhni chaye.warna ye to zabardasti hai k tum Rasool Mohammad(s.a.w) ko bhi maano aur gairo ki taqleed bhi karo. AUR MUJHE PATA HAI TUMHARE MASLAQ ME KYA KHICHDI PAKTE HAI KABHI APNE MASLAQ K KITAABON KO UTHA KAR DEKHO WARNA MUJHE danish_bluesky@yahoo.in par mail kijye page number k saath hawaala pesh karenge inshaallah. Aur agar mai jhoot kahoon to Allah mere upar azaab naajil ata farmaaye.
Mohammad Danish // January 26, 2009 at 2:55 pm |
Zakir nayak sahab sahi hai ya galat ye maslah nahi hona chaye kyo k Hujjat sirf Nabi hote hai aur koi nahi, ye mai nahi Quran kehta hai Apne Allaim se consult kijye…Koi Imam, koi Wali, koi Aalim Hujjat nahi hota Siwaye sarware Kainaath k(s.a.w).Quran aur Sahih hadees jab saamne aa jaaye to chup chaap Sur jhooka lena chaaye warna agar aaj agar Mohammad(S.A.W) hote Aur Wahi-e-ilahi agar jaari rehta to aise logo k upar kya fatwa Allah lagate aap samajh jaye, Ye waqya Sahaba Ikraam k saath ho chuka, Nabi k zamaane mai Allah ne har masle example k zariye dikhaye. Aur wo to Sahaba the jise Allah ne Duniya me hi bashaaarat sunayi phir bhi Allah ne unhe sakhti se pakda aur aaj ye Muqalid logo ka kya?
Mohammad Danish // January 26, 2009 at 3:04 pm |
Zakir Naik sahab coat aur pant pehente hai isliye aap Quran aur Hadees ko jhutla dijyega????Pehle ye to saabit kijye waisa dress islam mai haraam hai?
jahan tak mujhe sharya k principles ka knowledge hai poore Quran aur Hadees mai Dress design ka saboot nahi milta..Islam me hai k kapda tight na ho, transparent na ho, very attractive na ho, above the ankle na ho,wat else? warna mushrikin makkah bhi waise hi dress pehente they jaisa aaj mulla log pehente hai aur agar aap sahi hai to phir aapko bhi bohot saari cheezon ka boycott karna hoga, soch lijye??…ISLAM KO SHAKSIYAT SE MATH SAMAJHYE ISLAM KO QURAN AUR HADEES SE SAMAJHYE.
Mohammad Danish // January 26, 2009 at 3:12 pm |
ZAKIR NAYAK SAHAB SPEAKS GOOD.
IF ANYONE NEED THE POSTMORTEM REPORT OF THESE SO CALLED DEOBANDIS, MAIL ME AT DANISH_BLUESKY@YAHOO.IN.
HUM SAB UNITED TABHI HO SAKTE HAI JAB SIRF QURAN AUR SAHIH HADEES KO HI APNA YARDSTICK BANAYE WARNA JITNA BHI KOSHIS KARLO UNITED NAHI HO PAYEGE JUST WAT ALLAH SAID IN HIS BOOK…ASALAMWALIKUM WARAHMATULLAHIWABARAKATHU.
Mohammed Farhan // January 31, 2009 at 7:36 pm |
Assalam Alai Kum,
Brother Dr. Zakir Naik is a Muslim, and all others who are commenting on him are Muslims. Stop fighting for silly reasons because Allah knows who is right and who is wrong.
Tumhe is ka jawab khabar mein jane ke baad miljaye ga, is liye Allah se daroo, aur Musalman bhayioon par Tohmat lagana choddo, Allah tumhe Taufeeq de, Ameen.
Rizwan Ahmed // February 4, 2009 at 5:58 pm |
FATWA is one of Deoband’s weakness, if they doesnt have any answer they issue a Fatwa and all other gullible muqallideen knows neither A nor B of of the fact blindly accept it. May ALLAH show them the right path of QURAN and HADEES
tanim jubaer // February 9, 2009 at 7:03 am |
Assalam Alai Kum,
current moulanas are far away from true quranic knowledge, there,s doubt about their understanding of Islam and Allahtala. Most fatwas are so baseless that often goes aginst quranic principle.
I,ve a regular viewer of Dr. Naiks programme and never found anything agianst Quran
while many fatwa,s are based on muftis personal wisdom,refering books other than quran or sihah sittah
read quran more thers everything about your life
may allah help us from missguidence
afsha // February 23, 2009 at 9:11 pm |
whats wrong with sunni muslims.have they converted to shias.how shameful.instead of appreciating dr zakir naik they got mixed with shias.where is this great man dr zakir wrong.i know today these so called muslims neither can invite people to islam nor can they appreciate people who are into such marvellous work.how shame that these so called mullas who can just give fatwas and fatwas neither can clear any misconception about islam nor can they go for any debate as they are not qualified with their limited knowledge.only thing they can do is overpowering their wives.it is just because of these rubbish mullas that islam is misconcepted.shame on sunni mullas for what they have done.i think so they should be stoned to death for talking ill about the GREAT GREAT ZAKIR NAIK.ALHAMDULILLAH TODAY WE HAVE SUCH GREAT MEN.PRIDE OF ISLAM.LONG LIVE ZAKIR NAIK
AFSHA // February 23, 2009 at 9:48 pm |
who the hell is Lucknow’s shahar qazi Mufti Abul Irfan Mian Firangi Mahali to give a fatwa against zakir naik.is he qualified to stand against zakir naik.is he qualified to have debate with priest and pandits and athiests.this mulla might not even know the meaning of athiest.and how dare he issue a fatwa against zakir naik.first be qualified to spread islam scientifically and logically then dream about FATWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA.
Shahnawaz warsi // February 24, 2009 at 4:57 pm |
Miss Afsha I have Shown ur Dirty language on site to be shown to Others.
Plz tell how much u know about an Alim.?Fatwa?
Do U know u can not even make wuzu and Gusl if it would not have been told to u through Mualanas.
first Study Islam and its rich history.
Develop Respect towards Huzoor Nabi Kareem Sallaho alihiwassalam his Sahabis and Aulias.
Who are Ahle Bayt?
who is Yazeed?
May allah guide us the Straight Path.Amin
dhakir // February 24, 2009 at 6:54 pm |
they said its best to avoid, he may have knowledge, but as thye said, he doesnt follow a madhhab, and this is serious. i personally am a bit weary of him. he has a lot of knowledge, but doesnt meen he can, nor can anyone else, pick and choose their own veridcts without the correct knowledge, ir that of the 4 mujtahid imams
Sher-e-Ghousia // February 25, 2009 at 2:45 pm |
Shahnawaz Warsi Sahib, some people will see the truth whilst others won’t, no matter how much resources you throw at them.
Dr Naiks supporters claim the he has more knowledge when in comes to comparative religion. That is good, but what is it good for if you cannot even grasp the basics of your own religion.
Dr Naik and his supporters (including the Saudis) proudly keep hammering the point that they know more about other religions. But the real lovers of Allah Ta’ala and Sayyiduna RasoolAllah (sallalhu alayhi wa’salllam) take pride in knowing more about the beautiful religion of Islam.
There were many great Scholars of the past who did not know much about other religions, hence did not debate with individuals from these groups. Does that make them less credible?
Islam is not about debating, it is about understanding through compassion, love and enlightened knowledge.
I know it has not arrived but I may not get time, so, Eid-e-Milad-un-Nabi (sall’Allahu Ta’ala ‘alayhi wa’alihi wa’sallam) Mubarak to everyone.
Shahnawaz warsi // February 25, 2009 at 3:01 pm |
AsSalamolaikum Sher-e-Ghousia
How ru?
Plz find time to post new Items…and Comments.
thnx
Sher-e-Ghousia // February 26, 2009 at 3:22 am |
Walaykum as’salaam Shahnawaz Warsi,
Alhamdulillah, I am well.
Hazrat, I think it is time we stop wasting our time on this man. From the 100’s comments, it seems as though Dr Naiks followers are too blind and stubborn to accept that their “great scholar” can make mistakes.
On a previous thread, I provided evidence after evidence, but Dr Naiks supporters did not want to listen. They seem to think he is always right and merely provide their flimsy opinions to substantiate their outlandish and cowardice claims.
PS: When I get some time I will provide new items for this great space on the Internet, Insha’Allah Azza wa’jal.
imran // February 27, 2009 at 12:00 pm |
Dr zakir ka ilm apni jaga sahi ha magar kuch cheezain koi un se pooche k woh jo yeh Tie bante hain is Tie ki kiya history ha.why christian wears Tie.agar un ko pata chal jaye tu woh Tie phena chor denge.
Shahnawaz warsi // February 27, 2009 at 5:08 pm |
Thnx Sher-e-Ghousia..
U r correct when u says we need not to waste our time on these blind supporters.
hope to see ur contributions soon.
Muhammad Azam // February 28, 2009 at 6:03 am |
dear zakir naik i m totally 100 percent do not agree with your teachings in last months you disobey te teachings of imam hussain (A.S) by saying the battle of karbala (moazallah) the battle of politics on the other hand battle of karbala was fought for the saving of islam and dr israr ahmed maloon said that (moazallah) hazrat ali (A.S) drink wine and than pray (moazallah) israr ahmed maloon is simply kafir. And zakir naik i am saying that youare munafiq simply.
Muhammad Azam // February 28, 2009 at 6:05 am |
zakir naik tere zaat pay lanat bayshumar munkar of 12 imams (A.S)
imran // March 2, 2009 at 5:20 am |
4 ma se 1 Imaam ka maana bhut zrrori hai.Hadees shareef hum tak Sahaba-e-karam aur in 4 Imaam k zariye phunchi hai.No body can Prove that donkey is halal and haram with the help of Quran one have to go through HAdees to find the answer.is liye agar koi bhi 4 Imaam per yakeen nahi rakhta to woh hadees kahan se parhe ga aur khaali Quran se Namaz parhne ka tariqa kaise sekhe ga.Quran aur Sunnat both have to be followed.aur sunnat Hadees shareef se pata chalti hai aur hadees shareef 4 Imaam ne jama kari ha is per puri Umaat ka ijmaa hai.Saudi Arab ma bhi abhi tak Imaams ko follow kiya jata hai.
faizan // March 11, 2009 at 7:38 pm |
assalam alaikum
kay larka & larki jinka rista laga ho shaide se phali phon par bhat kar sakte hai ke nahi kar saktai hai to aur nahi kar saktai hai to do no ko hadith ke rosne me bataye
mohammed // March 28, 2009 at 3:58 pm |
Has anybody observed Zakir Naik physically? Apart from maintaining a weak physical structure, the most important observation to be made are from his facial appearance. Have you observed any saintly and pious man? Have you not noticed illuminous light from his eyes and graceful look on his face and the beauty of his beard and the gentle assuring smile and humility in his behaviour and attitude towards others? Can you observe this in Zakir? Is he not sarcastic in his words, actions, body language and what more parallels should I draw?
Basid Azmi // April 6, 2009 at 5:51 pm |
What Dr. Naik has done in a few years, these Fatwa policemen cannot do in 65 years.
These people are just jealous oh him.
He quotes nothing but the Quran n the right context.
He is driving ppl towards understanding the meaning of Quran .
This is hurting these ppl the most as their shops would be closed.
tabrez shaikh // April 8, 2009 at 9:57 pm |
i fail to understand how this idiotic Mr Naik can say may peace be upon him for yazeed .He puts logic in islam , which was never done by any prophet or sahaba . why he wanta to wear this tie all the time ,did anyone in the history of islam wore any thing like this . they wear it coz it resembles the cross of jesus christ that is where this tradition started from by the christians . if sania mirza is doing right according to him by wearing mini skirt then , then i dont know where he is going to take his followers may be in the PUBS OR OPEN A ZAKIR DISCO CLUB
tabrez shaikh // April 8, 2009 at 10:02 pm |
HE LOOKS VERY MUCH LIKE A MONKEY . GOD HAS REALLY MADE HIM VERY UGLY . I THINK HIS WIFE PISSES HIM OF EVERYDAY WHEN HE REACHES HOME AFTER FOOLING HIS FOOLISH FOLLOWERS AND KEEPS HIM HUNGRY BECAUSE OF WHICH HIS WEIGHT HAS COME DOWN TO 35 KGS.
Zareena // April 9, 2009 at 12:06 pm |
I love Zakir Naik,
My prayers for him is always from my depth of my heart
we need more peoples like him on this earth.
NAim // April 12, 2009 at 10:26 am |
Why do these guys remove my comment?
NAim // April 12, 2009 at 10:27 am |
Please call Zakir Naik Remtullah alaih
Shahnawaz warsi // April 13, 2009 at 9:05 am |
Mr Naim Ur Comments were abusive and not worthy of Publishing..be polite and thena rgue in a civilized manner.
Moderator
Sher-e-Ghousia // April 13, 2009 at 10:53 am |
tabrez shaikh, hold your horses my man. We should take the higher moral ground here. If others want to use foul language, let them, it just highlights their inner corruption. We should follow the Sunnah and address people within the boundaries that are in place.
Naim, are you certain of your request. The prefix ‘Ramathulahi alay’ – which means ‘may Allah have mercy on him’ – is used for those who have passed away.
Zareena, if you really love Dr Naik then you should try to help him. Get in touch and make him realize his mistakes so he can repent.
Zeshan Shehzad // April 14, 2009 at 6:32 am |
Dear All,
Dr. Zakir Naik is a sick mind not a genius. He neither knows Islam nor its heart—Sufism. If Islam means memory–210 GB–then a computer is a better Muslim than anyone living on the face of earth.
He is dae’e?…..He should practice dawah after being clear that he has truth in him…….. I am sure that he is a wahabi agent! He is non-idealist, non-metaphysical, not-spiritual goof. He is telling Muslims that Islam is matter of common sense—but actually it is matter of un-common sense! Only Sufis have real Islam—Zakir Naik is only mouth not heart!
Zeshan Shehzad // April 14, 2009 at 6:36 am |
@Zareena
It would be doomsday when world will be populated by Zakir Naiks——I think we need Ba Yazid Bastami Remtullah alaih and let this world be clean of Zakir Naiks in any religion.
Abdul // April 14, 2009 at 8:19 am |
Asslam u Elaikum
Alhamdulilah Dr Zakir Naik is doing a great job, i realy apreciate his efforts. these efforts will be greatful if he attire the islamic dress code and i would like to ask him hw far it is JAYAZ to give Zakat to his TV channel (peace TV). as far as we know zakat is for the needy people.
Naim // April 16, 2009 at 12:26 am |
Well just think for a while….can all these muqullids unite all muslims NO WAY….they say 4 imams are corret, further they have sub divisions in these 4 madhabs
Hadees says to be one, Quran says to be one, Hadees says only one firaaq will go in heaven ….but today’s maulvi says 4 are correct WOW…..
Only Naik is the coprrect man who is trying to unite the muslims. …
do you guys even see any other ulema providing so many proof’s ..
Believeing anyone without any proof is called taqleed which is not allowed in Islam
Sher-e-Ghousia // April 16, 2009 at 8:17 pm |
So Naim, let me get this straight. Your indicating that almost every Muslim since the Sahaba (Radi Allahu Ta’ala anhum ajma’eenn) where wrong because they followed an Imam, but somehow Zakir Naik is right.
Before going gung-ho on your proof campaign, first consider the people who established that Madhabs. Imam ibn Hanbal (radi Allahu ta’ala anh’) knew approximately 500,000 hadiths (including chains of narration, etc). Who in this time and age has memorized as many hadiths? NONE!
Allama Zia al Mustafa (I think he is in his 70’s) is one of the top Scholars of hadith at this time, but from what I have heard, he has memorized between 50,000 to 70,000 hadiths. Even such a great scholar of our time is no where near the 500,000 of Imam ibn Hanbal (radi Allahu ta’ala anh’)
My question to you is, who has the ability to make the better judgment, Imam ibn Hanbal, who has memorized 500,000 hadiths, or Zakir Naik, who has barely memorized a fraction of that?
yasir aziz // April 29, 2009 at 9:01 am |
Darul Ifta, Darul Uloom Deoband is one of the most ambigeous,chawal,jahil.pagal,greedy,people’s place
danish // April 30, 2009 at 3:26 pm |
TO SHER-E-GAUSIA…..Let me help u to go straight Mr Gausia… You said that Imam Abu Hanifa collected & memorized loads of hadeeth so we prefer to follow him, i dont know from which authenticated sources u informed us the quantity of memorized hadeeth anyway as i am a disbeliever of ur faith i wud like to know THE BOOK OF HADEETH compiled by ur Imam atleast one..?? You added that all these founderers of madhabs after Islam were great scholars , again if this is the case then u shud go for majority because Imam Malik(r), Imam Hambal(r) & Imam Shafa’i declared him DIVIATED in their books…Now wat?? In the light of blind faith you explained that they collected hadeeth in huge scales at the same time u cud not understand that Imam Bukhari(r), Imam Muslim(r) & other great scholars not only memorized the priceless sayings of beloved prophet(p.b.u.h) but rahter preserved it for upcoming generations, they used to travel for days to collect one single hadeeth along with the faith & chain of purities, why dont u all make them also stand as a candidate in the competition of establishing madhabs?? The word Hadeeth does not suit on the mouth of Muqallids as they are known to represent the sayings of imam & others not prophet..They are the GAIR-MUQALLIDS who feel the value of priceless hadeeth & only they have the right to represent the sayings of Beloved Prophet(p.b.u.h)……I dont want to go further anymore because once i will start to speak against the book of hanafis on which their faith & madhabs is based on then i m sure that the jews & christains will start to celebrate if any in this room bcoz they’ll bag an oppurtunity to malign pure Islam. The book is HIDAAYA & i am ashamed that hanafi follow such book.
Haider // May 2, 2009 at 10:30 pm |
Danish, you have completely missed my point. I was not comparing the Ulema of the past, but asking the question, who has the better judgment. Is it the person who knows more (Imam Abu Hanifa radi Allahu Ta’ala anh’) or the one who knows less ( Dr Zakir Naik)?
Since you mentioned Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim (radi Allahu Ta’al Anhuma), let me ask you one question. Have you read the biography of these two giants of Hadith compilation? If you have, you would know that they also followed established Madhabs.
PS: A kind tip; learn before writing. The Hanafi Madhab is concentrated towards Fiqh’ and not Aqida (or faith as you call it). If you cannot accept differences of opinions in matters of Fiqh’, then that is your problem.
mohammad lateef bhat // May 4, 2009 at 12:33 pm |
asalamualiakum warahmatullallah
such a fatwa on eminent dawee of islam like Dr Zakir is not justified and saying that he is misleading the youth is a big shame for our brothers who do oeffer the fatwas like this. actually as per me it is not Dr Zakir who is misleading people but it is u.he is doing prophets job and allah would definetly reward him with jannat. see how many were converted by GOD to islam thru him. finally biggest loss to us is that we are making ourself a laughing point please abstain from these devilish work .donot let this bloody indian media to attack us.
thanks
danish // May 4, 2009 at 5:44 pm |
Hey Haider wat r u talking all about, i cudn’t get it…brother u claimed that Imam Bukhari(r) & Muslim(r) followed the madhab of man made isnt it?? Just let me know the source where these great men had HIMSELF SAID & WRITTEN THAT THEY FOLLOWED THOSE NONSENCE..I challenge!!!! U added that who can judge better, those Imams or Zakir naik, Isnt it? Is this the Islam u r following? Shame..Wat about Nabi(S.A.W)?? He said nothing in his lifetime?? or he said that follow the upcoming imam?? Let me state my faith i.e. EVERY LIVING BEING CAN MAKE MISTAKE & CAN BE DIVIATED WHETHER HE IS ZAKIR OR HANIFA BUT MY IMAM & MY PROPHET MUHAMMAD(S.A.W) NEITHER MADE ANY MISTAKE NOR HE HAD GIVEN THE WORLD ANYTHING WHICH IS AGAINST MY LORD!! Correct?? if ur imam has collected some hadees indeed with correct ISNAAD then its enough for us to keep shut when the word of the Beloved prophet(S.A.W) has arrived then there’ll b nothing to fight but If u’ll say follow these man made madhabs then without any thinking i’ll kick it off & i’ll be not asked for this in the hereafter INSHALLAH!!
danish // May 4, 2009 at 6:04 pm |
U added that we do not follow Imam abu hanifa in faith, isnt it?? IT MEANS HIS FAITH WAS NOT OK???? brother uptil now i have spoken about the basics only..Once I’ll open the gate of these schools of teachings then u’ll find those jewels which ur Imams has given to this UMMAH..ITS SHAMELESS & i dont know whether Imam Hanifa had himself gave those fatwas or the others because Imam hanifa in his lifetime did not compiled a single book..350yrs after hanifa people established this madhab with the label of IMAM HANIFA..
Rightly said Allah in his Glorious book” Do they not then consider the Qur’an carefully? Had it been from other than Allah, they wud surely have found therein many a contadiction”(Surah An Nisa)
MUHAMMAD AQEEL GUL // May 5, 2009 at 1:29 pm |
i want to get admission in madarsa plz tell me about great madaris in pakistan
Haider // May 6, 2009 at 5:50 pm |
Danish, you seem to construct your own ideas regarding the context of my comments. Let’s get some things straight.
Firstly, go and read Naim’s comments, and you will clearly see what I’m “talking all about”. Naim is claiming that Zakir Naik right and those before him were wrong. Hence, why I asked a simply logical question, which you seem to have taken completely out of context.
Secondly, I like all Muslim follow the ways of Sayyiduna Rasool’Allah (sallallahu alayhi wasslam).
Thirdly, the Hanifa Madhab is a manual on Fiqh’ and not Aqida. This is why we follow Imam Hanifa (radi Allahu Ta’ala anh’) on matters of Fiqh’. Again, you have taken things out of context.
Where did you get your information from? For example, the figure of 350 years. Read ‘The Muwatta of Imam Muhammad’ By Imam Abu Hanifa’s (radi Allahu Ta’ala anh’) student Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Shaybani for a better perspective.
Your insistent on Hadith and chains of narration shows me someone who knows something about the subject. So, let me ask you a couple of questions:
1) Is the usage of a weak Hadith permissible?
2) If there are two ‘Sahih’ narrations contradicting each other, what would you do?
Since you finished with an Ayah, let me do the same also. In surat al-Nahl, “Ask those who recall, if you know not” (Qur’an 16:43).
PS: I cannot find the source of where it shows that Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim (radi Allahu Ta’al Anhuma) followed Madhabs. If I find it, I’ll let you know, Insha’Allah Azza wa’jal. For now, have a read of ‘Understanding the four Madhabs’ by Shaykh Abdal-Hakim Murad. The Shaykh mentions it in there.
danish // May 7, 2009 at 8:44 am |
Brother Haider again u r stretching the small syllabus.
I m asking u a simple question i.e. u have denied to follow Imam Hanifa in faith. WHY??
Secondly u doudted whether the usage of week narration is acceptable or not. isnt it?? Answer is very clear for the men of understanding, Islam speaks about ‘BURHAAN, SULTAN, BAYYINH’..e.g. Quran speaks: ‘ qul haatu burhaanukum in kuntum saadiqeen’ which means “say Produce ur proof if u all r indeed truthful”.. Let me explain the term’BURHAAN’ firstly brother nowhere in the Quran Allah asks for ‘DALEEL’ but burhaan,sultan&etc, there is a vast differences between these terms. Arabs defines the word BURHAAN by giving an example i.e. closest part of the sun indicating the place where the sunlight is maximum. Allah(s.w.t) used this term because he wants the proof which cannot be rejected or cannot be questioned in short the proof with maximum light in it but if u ask for daleel then for a while even a christain, jew, shi’a,hanafi,etc can produce it & can convince the mind of few or nil person.isnt it? Now i m asking u i.e. if someone asks me about any Maslah regarding Islam wat shud i produce. week or sahih narration?? Between u & me there is a bunches of contradictions, how to solve it?? IN THE PRESENCE OF SAHIH HADEETH U CANNOT ADOPT WEEK NARRATIONS, NO NEED OF IT, TO THIS POINT ENTIRE SCHOLARS OF ISLAM HAS IZMAA EVEN IMAM ABU HANIFA. There is a huge possibility of going astary & conflict if we take week narration as a yard-stick where Islam encourages clarity.isnt it? Only a fool can go for stale bread in the availibility of fresh one.
Secondly u questioned that what to do if two sahih narrations contradicts? brother If anyone say that Quran contradicts itself, wat’ll u say??Scholars of islam has catagorised the ayah of Quran into two catogories- 1. Ayat-e-Mohkamath- easily recognised. 2. Ayat-e-Motasabehath- Not easily recognised which means it requires deep understanding with pure faith & ofcourse the way sahabas & tabai understood it. In the sameway hadeeth can be also catogarised into these two catogories, since hadees is a part of islamic teachings it cannot contradicts this is wat a muslim believes, Allah has preserved his deen from the mixtures, so he sent persons like Bukhari(r), Muslim(r),Malik(r), Shafai(r), Humbal(r), Abu Dawood(r), Tirmidhi(r), Haakim(r) all of them checked themselves & each others narrations & catogorised it into saheeh & daeef,they never promoted Taqleed. Since u have asked me about contradictions then plz let me know few contradictions so that i can work on it. AND BROTHER AS I TOLD U BEFORE THAT I HAVEN’T OPEN THE GATE OF THESE SCHOOL UPTIILL NOW OTHERWISE U’LL FORGET THE WORD ‘COTRADICTION’, U’LL COME TO KNOW HOW IT INSULTS THE SHARI’A OF ALLAH(S.W.T) MOREOVER THERE IS A HUGE CONTRADICTIONS AMONG IMAM MALIK(R), IMAM HUMBAL(R), IMAM SHAFAI(R) & IMAM ABU HANIFA NOW I M ASKING U WAT TO DO UNDER THIS CIRCUMSTANCES???
Brother that book is not compiled by Imam Abu Hanifa but after Imam Abu Hanifa, check it out or can i help u?? And again why u dont follow Imam hanifa in faith??? In the next post I’ll explain u the hidden meaning of the verse u quoted from Quran Insha’Allah,brother forgive me now coz i have work at office. IN FIQH I CAN SEE A MOUNTIAN OF COTRADICTIONS.Brother learn to walk alone. on the day of judgement if Allah will qualify u for Jannah (Insha’allah) then ull b indeed sucessful and suppose at the same time Imam Hanifa will not qualify for it. Tell me will it make any difference to u??
danish // May 7, 2009 at 8:49 am |
Brother Haider again u r stretching the small syllabus.
I m asking u a simple question i.e. u have denied to follow Imam Hanifa in faith. WHY??
Secondly u doudted whether the usage of week narration is acceptable or not. isnt it?? Answer is very clear for the men of understanding, Islam speaks about ‘BURHAAN, SULTAN, BAYYINH’..e.g. Quran speaks: ‘ qul haatu burhaanukum in kuntum saadiqeen’ which means “say Produce ur proof if u all r indeed truthful”.. Let me explain the term’BURHAAN’ firstly brother nowhere in the Quran Allah asks for ‘DALEEL’ but burhaan,sultan&etc, there is a vast differences between these terms. Arabs defines the word BURHAAN by giving an example i.e. closest part of the sun indicating the place where the sunlight is maximum. Allah(s.w.t) used this term because he wants the proof which cannot be rejected or cannot be questioned in short the proof with maximum light in it but if u ask for daleel then for a while even a christain, jew, shi’a,hanafi,etc can produce it & can convince the mind of few or nil person.isnt it? Now i m asking u i.e. if someone asks me about any Maslah regarding Islam wat shud i produce. week or sahih narration?? Between u & me there is a bunches of contradictions, how to solve it?? IN THE PRESENCE OF SAHIH HADEETH U CANNOT ADOPT WEEK NARRATIONS, NO NEED OF IT, TO THIS POINT ENTIRE SCHOLARS OF ISLAM HAS IZMAA EVEN IMAM ABU HANIFA. There is a huge possibility of going astary & conflict if we take week narration as a yard-stick where Islam encourages clarity.isnt it? Only a fool can go for stale bread in the availibility of fresh one.
Secondly u questioned that what to do if two sahih narrations contradicts? brother If anyone say that Quran contradicts itself, wat’ll u say??Scholars of islam has catagorised the ayah of Quran into two catogories- 1. Ayat-e-Mohkamath- easily recognised. 2. Ayat-e-Motasabehath- Not easily recognised which means it requires deep understanding with pure faith & ofcourse the way sahabas & tabai understood it. In the sameway hadeeth can be also catogarised into these two catogories, since hadees is a part of islamic teachings it cannot contradicts this is wat a muslim believes, Allah has preserved his deen from the mixtures, so he sent persons like Bukhari(r), Muslim(r),Malik(r), Shafai(r), Humbal(r), Abu Dawood(r), Tirmidhi(r), Haakim(r) all of them checked themselves & each others narrations & catogorised it into saheeh & daeef,they never promoted Taqleed. Since u have asked me about contradictions then plz let me know few contradictions so that i can work on it. AND BROTHER AS I TOLD U BEFORE THAT I HAVEN’T OPEN THE GATE OF THESE SCHOOL UPTIILL NOW OTHERWISE U’LL FORGET THE WORD ‘COTRADICTION’, U’LL COME TO KNOW HOW IT INSULTS THE SHARI’A OF ALLAH(S.W.T) MOREOVER THERE IS A HUGE CONTRADICTIONS AMONG IMAM MALIK(R), IMAM HUMBAL(R), IMAM SHAFAI(R) & IMAM ABU HANIFA NOW I M ASKING U WAT TO DO UNDER THIS CIRCUMSTANCES???
Brother that book is not compiled by Imam Abu Hanifa but after Imam Abu Hanifa, check it out or can i help u?? And again why u dont follow Imam hanifa in faith??? In the next post I’ll explain u the hidden meaning of the verse u quoted from Quran Insha’Allah,brother forgive me now coz i have work at office. IN FIQH I CAN SEE A MOUNTIAN OF COTRADICTIONS.Brother learn to walk alone. on the day of judgement if Allah will qualify u for Jannah (Insha’allah) then ull b indeed sucessful and suppose at the same time Imam Hanifa will not qualify for it. Tell me will it make any difference to u on that hard day??
Haider // May 8, 2009 at 5:23 pm |
I like quotes, so I’ll start with one and finish with another. Cf. Imam al-Dajawi, II (579) said:
“By Allah, this view (that ordinary people should not follow madhhabs) is nothing less than an attempt to fling the door wide open for people’s individual preferences, thereby turning the Book and the Sunna into playthings to be manipulated by those deluded fools, driven by their compounded ignorance and their corrupt imaginings.”
1) I follow Imam Abu Hanifa in Fiqh and follow Imam Ashari in Aqida. Since, both their Aqida is the same (apart from intricate details) and in line with the Ahle Sunnah wal Jama’ah, in essence I abide by the same Aqida as Imam Abu Hanifa.
2) I know there are differences between the Madhabs, and there are also differences within the Madhabs themselves. Even the Companions differed in the opinions. Islam is blessed with the scope for having differences of opinion but yet being right at the same time. If you cannot accept differences of opinions then that is your problem.
3) Regarding contradictions amongst the Madhabs, I’m sorry to say, you have clearly demonstrated your lack of understanding here. A Muslim (Sunni) follows only ONE of the Madhabs. But at the same time we accept all four Madhabs to be correct, as differences of opinion in matters of Fiqh’ is permissible.
4) No thanks, I don’t want commentary of the Qur’an by you. I’ve got access to the works from the likes of Imam Qastali, Imam Shawqani, Shah Abdul Aziz Dehlavi and so on.
5) You go on about evidences, but yet you fail to provide any yourself.
6) I asked you whether the usage of a weak Hadith is permissible. You replied in the negative and claimed “There is a huge possibility of going astray”. Actually, it is permissible to use weak Hadith, but only for:
- Matters of Fiqh’
- For acts of Thawab
- If there is no other Hadith contradicting it
- Must be in line with the Sharia
Read the classical books on Usul-ul-Hadith, and you will find this to be true.
The reason I asked you the questions – especially the first – was to determine whether this discussion was worth continuing. Before I have a discussion with people like you (mainly pseudo-Salafis) I ask them some questions to determine whether it is worthwhile having a dialogue with them. If they cannot answer the questions satisfactorily I do not discuss religious matters with them, because I will point out that such is permissible but the other person will just yell this is wrong, this is bid’a and so on without any justification.
I expected someone to show better understanding. Instead, like many people I have met who are against the established Madhabs, you keep making claims without any credible justification. You seem to be making up your own Usul on Tafsir and Hadith.
You have failed to answer correctly, so I’ll leave this discussion there. If you want to carry on, I’ll let someone let takeover, or if not, please head over to the YaNabi.com forums, where there are brothers who have the patience to discuss with you. You can claim all you want, my shift regarding this matter is finished.
Finally, you asked me to walk alone. If you want to then by all means do so, but I’m not. I’m going to walk with the giants and pious predecessors of the Ahle Sunnah wal Jamma’ah, Isha’Allah Azza’ wa’jal.
Let me finish with this quote, which is directed towards the anti-Madhab brigade:
“Instead of four madhhabs in harmony, we will have a billion madhhabs in bitter and self-righteous conflict. No more brilliant scheme for the destruction of Islam could ever have been devised.”
Ya Ali Madad
danish // May 9, 2009 at 10:41 am |
Agian brother nowhere in the comments i can see a person who seeks knowledge.
U quoted the word of an Ummati named Al-Dajawi & judged the path of salvation, dont u think seeking kowledge is obligatory to every muslim??
Our beloved prophet(p.b.u.h) said “I have been
sent to complete the best morals.” (Al-Hakim and Adh-Dhahabi)- Sahih narration.Which means Our Prophet’s(p.b.u.h) sayings, actions, sunnah, etc is the only way to salvation.
Quoting the words of an ummati cannot solve any disputes, if indeed i have spoken anything false its ur duty to rectify it otherwise i’ll catch u hereafter. isnt it? And as far as i m concerned knowledge is the ultimate way to hidaayath this is wat our beloved Nabi(S.A.W) & His Lord said that whenever Allah gifts someone with hidaayath he gives him the knowledge of Deen. Allah says “This book(Quran) is for the men of understanding” in other place He added ” Many recieves admonition from it & some diviates”. What does these verses means?? To whom u’ll fit the last verse?
I cannot get ur Logic brother sometimes u say that we follow Ashuri in faith & sometimes u stick with hanifa saying both of them were correct. I guess Ashuri was the person with WAHDATUL-WAJOOD aqida but Imam Abu hanifa was against it. Since we belongs to Ahle sunnah wal jammaa we believe the person with wahdatul wajood is a KAAFIR. Open the book of ur akaabirs u’ll find all of them promoted wahdatul wajood for e.g haji Imdad’ullah Makki. Even hanifa gave the fatwa against it declaring ‘KAAFIR’. I hope u know wat is wahdatul wajood??
Your next point i.e. opinions may go different isnt it? Your ignorance proves that u dont know anything about Shari’a. THERE IS A VAST DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OPINIONS & SHARI’A. Even the opinions of Sahabas(r) cannot be included in the syllabus of Shari’a unless certified by Nabi(s.a.w), This is the deen of Allah(s.w.t) none has the right to pass opinion over it. ‘ Once a sahaba(r) from Shaam came to Abdullah ibn Umar(r) & asked him whether performing hajj tamaktu is allowed or forbidden, to this Abdullah ibn Umar(r) replied with YES. That Shaami Sahaba(r) got unsatisfied & said BUT I HEARD FROM YOUR FATHER THAT ITS ALLOWED, within no time Abdullah ibn Umar(r) replied MY FATHER HAS DISALLOWED IT BUT MY PROPHET(P.B.U.H) DIDNT.TO WHOM WE FOLLOW??(Tirmizi: kitaab Hajj). So this was the aqidah of sahabas(r) & since we belongs to the same jammat we too follow the same aqidah. See, Gair-Nabi can make mistakes it doesnt mean we’ll stick on it, the use of opinion can be felt when the solution is not present in the Book(Quran+Hadees).This is our aqidah, HUJJAT SIRF NABI HOTE HAIN UMMATI NAHI exactly what Quran indicates.
Next u said 4 imams were correct. Let me explain this calculation 2+2=4, 2+2=5, 2+2=7, 2+2=10. And person like u will take all of these calculations as a correct. Isnt it? Brother I cannot inderstand this calculation, plz dont insist me to follow it otherwise ill fail in exam. I cant understand why the Word of Allah & His prophet(p.b.u.h) cannot go into your throat.
Next according to you I have failed to show the proofs. Isnt it? I ask what proofs do you want, do you want Allah Himself to step down and make u convinced??
Next you explained where to fit the week hadeeth.First give me the Moral of this precious explanation brother as far as Saheeh hadeeth is concerned.
Next brother brother u found me a person with nil religious knowledge, so its an oppurtunity for fishing, You’ll get unlimited reward if u show me the way of islam, Brother plz dont deny me if i m nil with knowledge, its ur duty.
SAYING YA ALI MADAD IS SHIRK AKBAR, ONLY A MUSHRIK CAN SAY THIS.
Even the faith of MUSHRIKEEN-E-MAKKAH was far better than yours. GIVE ME THE PROOF EXCEPT THE FABRICATED ONE THAT WHY U PEOPLE CALL ALI(R) IN THE PRESENCE OF ALLAH(S.W.T). I can produce thousands of burhaan to proof that this can lead nowhere but HELL.
“Indeed in the Messenger of Allaah you have a good example to follow…”(Qur’an 33:21).
“I have left among you two things: you will never go astray as long as you hold fast to them: the Book of Allaah and my Sunnah.” (Al-Hakim)
“Then, by your Lord, We shall surely question them all, about what they used to do.” [(15), Al-Hijr, 92-93] “
Haider // May 9, 2009 at 3:34 pm |
I said that I’m finished with this discussion. But before I go let me clarify a couple of issues.
I never said you have “nil knowledge”, as I respect that you have a certain amount of knowledge. All I said was that I expected a certain level from you, but you didn’t reach that level.
As I said earlier, you can claim all you want, I’m not concerned. If you want to call me a “mushrik”, that is your choice. I don’t want to go down to your level and start labeling you with names. I’ll take the higher morale ground here, Insha’Allah Ta’ala.
You can fly like a butterfly and sting like a bee, but there is nothing like saying Ya Ali!
kashif // May 9, 2009 at 10:07 pm |
Just because Dr. Zakir Naik wears a suit does not bans him from ISLAM.
Moreover, He only talks of pure Islam and not of the sects, which is hurting the HALWA of MULLA’s.
I ask the MULLAS, pray tell me where it is written in Quran or Hadith that wearing a suit is HARAM?
Danish // May 10, 2009 at 8:26 am |
” Their likeness is as the likeness of one who kindled a fire; then, when it lighted all around him, Allah took away their light & left them in darkness, they could not see. They are deaf, dumb & blind, so they return not (to the right path)….”- Surah Baqarah.
To make alert someone from commiting SHIRK & restrict him from being MUSHRIK was the opening of Tableeg of Entire Nabi May Allah exalt their mansion, its not going down from a point of level but rather enhance the level up…Whats ur opinion about Quran where it states “Qul Ya-ayuhal Kaafiroon, La abadu Ma tabadun wala antum abiduna ma aabud, wala ana abidum ma abad tum wala antum abiduna ma aabud, lakum dinakum waliyadin” ( Surah kafiroon) Now check out the meaning of this great verses of Quran and ask yourself whether Quran degrades its level.
you are not an enemy of mine neither u have abused my father or mother, all i was trying just to make u feel the yard-stick in Islam. Hidaayath belongs to Allah & ofcourse there is no compulsion in religion. Remember one thing ‘ hidaayath bring violence at first, its upon you to be among SAABIROON so that peace can be obtained forever’.
PARADISE IS FORBIDDEN UPON THEM WHO COMMIT SHIRK, THIS WAS THE ONLY GREAT REASON WHY ALLAH SENT HIS MESSENGERS. May Allah give U Hidaayath-Ameen. For any hepl in future just remember ‘CHECKED_PERSONILITY@LIVE.COM’
Arshad Ali // June 4, 2009 at 8:16 pm |
Asslamalaikum warahmatullahhi wabarakatuhu
I like Dr. Zakir naik . lekin mujhe lagta hai ki wo kuch batien soch samajh kar nahi bolte maslan unki kuch baton me overconfidence nazar aata hai. kya wo tabligh jamat walon ko bura kahte hai.
SHAHID mahmood // June 8, 2009 at 2:03 am |
In Pakistan Dr zakir naik is popular among all firqas especially among young pople,reasons are many but most importantly because he proves his points both from Quran and science,please spare him from fatwagardi.
mohammed younus // June 10, 2009 at 6:02 am |
do u think dr zaker nayek is an aalam, no he is not, he is not an alam of sharia but an alam for doctorism
Jabe Raymond // June 13, 2009 at 8:01 am |
Hey I am American and I didn’t know anything about Islam, initially, but it was later on the account after 9/11 I became keenly interested. I think Zakir Naik is not just the man of words but he knows his game well, he walks the talk. I ‘ve heard him a lot of times, while he has a habit or style of refering to the actual quotes in Quran or other religons, I belive thats the brand most people should adhere. I belive this Fatwa over him is just plain birdbrained calls of desperate attention. If they knew what he meant while was saying that you can’t ask Prophet Mohammed(PBUH) he was referring to TAUHEED, and that one must ask only Allah for forgiveness or anything he wants. Because it is only Allah, not even his Prophet who can fulfil the promises. A person who belives otherwise is commiting SHIRIKH for which there is not Pardon and is the biggest sin, One must Pray to only Allah, no one else.Say: He is God the Only; God the Indivisible; He gives not birth, nor is He begotten, and He is, in Himself, not dependent on anything” (Sura 112:1-4)
“Thy Lord is the Absolute, the Lord of Mercy. If He will, He can remove you and can cause what He will to follow after you, even as He raised you from the seed of other folk.” (Sura 6:133)
As far as taking Osama’s side is concerned, he was just being nuteral, which most people are not and that is what makes it so different and alien to the ears. The bottom line is YOU NEED TO BACK UP WHAT YOU SAY WITH PROOFS, UNLIKE THESE IGNORANT ULEMAS!!!!!!
BTW, I’m a MOZLEM NOW…….THANKS TO THE WELL READ SCHOLARS LIKE Dr. Zakir Naik
ANUM // June 18, 2009 at 5:57 pm |
AUZU BILAAH HI MINASH SHITUAN NIRA JEEM BISMILHA HIRAH MAN NIRA HEM ASALAM O ALIKOM ALL’ YE SACH HA K HMY ALLHA K SATH KISI KO SHARIK NAI THERANA CAHE HMY DIRECT ALLHA SY MAGNA CAHYE CAHEY WO AK NEEDL HI KUN NA HO DR ZAKIR NAIK THEEK KAHTY HA HMY QURAN SAMJH K PARHNA CAHE YE SB QURAN SY SAIT HA K JO ALLHA K SATH SHIRK THRAYE GA US PER DUZAKH HARAM HA SURAT NISA AYAT NUM 116 M HA” YAKEENAN ALLHA IS BAT KO NAI BAKSHY GA K ISS K SATH KISI KO SHIRK THRAYA JAE AUR US K SIWA JISEY CAHEY GA BAKSH DY GA AUR JIS NY ALLHA K SATH SHIRK THRAYA WO RAHY RAST PER NAI I HOPE AP SAMJH GAE HOGY
ANUM // June 18, 2009 at 6:33 pm |
YE AYAT TOOHEED K BARY M HA AUR TOOHEE KA MATLB HA KISI B ZAT KO AK MANANA AUR wo allha hi ki zat ha aur shirk ka matlb ha SAJHA PAN (KISI AK KAM KO DO LOG KAREN WO SHIRK HOTA HA) aur allha hamari sounta ha agr hm ye sochen k hm kis auliya karam k zarye mange to wo hmy dyga but ye galt ha allha to hamari sharag sy b ziada kareeb ha hm ye kun nai sochty k wo auliya kasey baney ? quran aur sunat k zariye . agr hm ye sochty han k itni barhi kaynat ha to allha kasey sony ga to iska jawab ye hasurat tuaha m ha k ( agr allha ko madad gar ki zarorat hoti to allha un ko tb peda krta jb wo akela hota) hmy just allha sy mangna cahe usi ki zat ha jo hmy deti ha
shaid apko is sher sy kch samjh ajae
JO LA KAHA WO LA HOA
WO LA BI USS M LA HOA
JUZ LA HOA KOOL LA HOA
PHR KIA HOA ALHA HOA
LA MEAN=NAHI
JUZ MEAN=
KOOL MEAN=SAB KCH
HUM ye bat kio nai sam,jhty k agr hum allha ki tarf hath barhaty ha to wo bazo agy krta ha agr hum ak kadam chal kr jaty han to wo dorh kr hamari sonta ha
ak banda 40 sal sy ak pathr ko poj raha tha aur ya sanam ya sanam kahta tha ak din usy ung i aur galti sy usky mo sy YA SAMAD nikal gaya aur awaz ai LABAEK us bndy ny kaha to kon ha ALLHA NY KAHA m tera RAB ho aur 40 sal sy m intzar kr raha tha k to galti sy YA SAMAD kahy to m teri sono
is sy ye bat sabit hoi k hmy sirf ALLHA sy magna cahe
mushrik log dozakh m jaen gy
agr kisi ko kch pochna ho to pak.haya@Yahoo.com per poch sakty ha
Girish // June 25, 2009 at 8:33 pm |
I think this Zakir Naik is an idiot and the fatwa is right in condemning him. He uses some terrible logic in his speeches.
When asked why it is not ok for islamic countries to allow non-muslims to practice their religion, He says, Does a school want to hire a teacher who says 2+2=4 or one who says 2+2=3? In the same way, islamic countries only allow islam to be practiced.
To a follow up question, Cant the same logic be applied by non-muslim countries and should not allow muslims to practice their religion..well then he doesn;t have any good answer. He takes granted that will not happen and he probably might be thinking a Jihad (read suicide bombing) will automatically make any govt fall to its knees.
His logic is worse than that of a 10 year old and you people consider him to be scholar. Only Allah help him with some sense.
Mughal // June 26, 2009 at 10:14 am |
I quote: “We do not have DETAILS about Dr. Zakir Naik, only WE KNOW that he is an agent of Ghair Muqallideen, away from knowledge and wisdom, spreading mischievous things and misguiding simple Muslims to wrong path.”
If you have no details about him then how can you claim to know him? Do you even know him, have met him or talked with him?
I think it is YOU who are spreading mischievous things about Dr Zakir Naik, without any proof or evidence or details.
On the Day of Judgement, Allah will not Judge you on what clothes you were wearing, or what you looked like. Rather you will be judged on your deeds and actions, and your intentions leading to those actions.
So fear Allah and dont slander and backbite. If what you have said about zakir is wrong then you have slandered him, and if what you said is true then you have backbited him. As long as he professes to be a muslim and is not doing any major sin, then leave him alone.
Hicham // July 15, 2009 at 7:36 am |
Dr.Zakir Naik is one of the best in our period i wish we have jus one like him in each country in our planet
i have only one wish is to translate his debate on other languages so other people can undesrstand as well
God protect You Dr.
TABREZ // July 19, 2009 at 6:58 am |
Join for free daily Islamic SMS on Your Mobile ,send- ”JOIN HINDALWALI” to 567678 .For Indians Only
faizan // July 19, 2009 at 1:32 pm |
assalamualaikum
these wicked dev bandis (the slaves of cursed satan) are mis guiding the simple muslims .they say to follow imam abu hanifa,when imam abu hanifa has said to that -follow me!
the dev bandis aalims are really a curse to muslim ummah
waris // August 1, 2009 at 10:42 am |
O muslim, lets not be divided for trifle matter but united and clear our point in common interest of entire muslim. May ALLAH bring peace.
Ashraf // August 5, 2009 at 8:31 pm |
ASLLAM O ALICUM mein sirf ye kehna chahta hun k is fatway ka koi prove nahi hai, agar waqai koi fatwa laganay wala hai to wo Dr. Zakir k samany ja kr lagay.. ta k wo us k her swaal ka jawab bhi day sakay.. if you have dare to ask…..
Khalil Ahmed Qureshi // August 11, 2009 at 8:12 pm |
ASLLAM O ALICUM main Dr naik sahab ko hindu aur muslim ko nazdeek laney ke liye unka shukriya adaa karata hoon aur dev bandi alim se gujarish karata hoon ki naram rukh apnaye. I Ask you a simple question that wearing a suit is HARAM?
Shahzad Shaikh // August 17, 2009 at 3:09 am |
Dearest Muslims,
AOA,
Please do not hate each other maslik, All are the Muslims, who believed that Allah is One and The Muhammad Peace be upon him (Sal-lal-lah-ho-a-le-he wass-sal-lam) is the last prophet of Allah. The day of judgment will be show each other who was on right path. At the present time we should be unite because non Muslims are being happy to see us that we are against each other masalik. May Allah unite us.
Shahzad Shaikh // August 17, 2009 at 3:13 am |
We are agreed with your comments, that the Muslims should be unite.
Moh'd. Shamimuddin // August 18, 2009 at 11:18 am |
Aaj Musalmanon ki izzat aur wajod khatre mein hai sirf hamare ikhtilaf ki wajah se. Hamara Allah ek, Quran ek aur Kalma ek phir ikhtilaf kaisa. Hamare Nabi (SAW) ne kaha hum sab bhai bhai hain. Bus is sunnat pe amal karen aur pls. sari baton ko taaq per rakkhen.
Allah hum sub ko hidayat de – A’amin
Imran Ahmed // August 21, 2009 at 10:05 pm |
ASSALAMU WALAIKUM W RAHMATULLAH W BARKA’AT HU
Bhai BILAL.
Imran Ahmed // August 21, 2009 at 11:00 pm |
ASSALAMU WALAIKUM W RAHMATULLAH W BARKA’AT HU.
‘Bissmillahi rrahman nirrahiM’
Bhai BILAL.
Mai aap ke baaton se behad saimath hoon, aur samajhta hoon ke aap ne bilkul durast baten kahi hai.
Hadees sharif me ata hai ke Huzur Nabi Akram (Sallallah hu alaye hi w sallam) ne irshad farmaya ke Allah ta’ala farmata hai ke ‘Fazl’ mere raham dil bandon(Aulliya Allah) se mango in ke daman me ‘Ayesh’ karo ge, ke mai ne apni ‘Rahmat’ in me rhaki hai.
To bata’en jo koi shaks sirf ‘Kalma’ padh kar ya maa ke peth se muslman paida hota hai aur Amaal ki bunyad par ye kahta hai ke, Aullia se kuch mangna ‘Shirk’ hota hai wo kaisa jahil hoga.
Ek baat acchi tarha yaad rhak len ke beshak har Cheese ka ata karne wala to Allah ta’ala hi hai, magar ye soch kar ke Aulliya Allah, ek ‘Wasila’ hain Allah ta’ala ki raza ka, ye soch kar mangna shirk nahi hota, bhale hi hum un se hi kyun na mange unhe ‘YA’ kahe kar pukare.
SHIRK:
‘Wo gunnah jis ki koi muafi nahi, jo ke sab se bada gunnah hai Aur jis se Imaan chala jata hai’.
Aap ki roz marrah ki zindagi main aap ne dekha ho ga, ke jis ghar me chote na samajh bache hote hai us ghar ke bade buzrg kis qadar cheezon ka Ahtemam w Ahteyat karte hain, jaise ‘Chaqu ya churi’ koi is tarha nahi rhakta ke koi bache ka haat pahunch jaye, koi jalane wali cheez ya koi Zaherili Cheez jis se jaan ka dar ho koi iss tarha nahi rhakta ke kisi bache ya nasamajh admi ke pahunch me aye, baghair iss ke wo iss baat ka Aheteyat rhakta hai ke kahin un cheezon se koi Zakhmi na ho jaye. Har koi yahi soch rhakta hai….!
Ab ek lamhe ke liye ye sochen ke, ek Insaan ho kar koi iss qadar ahetiyat rhakta hai apne na samajh bache ke liye aur iss par bhi use chain nahi rahta, to bataiye wo hamara rabb jo hume Ashraf ul maqlukat kahta hai jo hum se itni mohabbat karta hai jini koi maa apne bache se nahi karti, itni shf’aqat, jitna koi baap apne bache se nahi karta wo Shirk ko humare itne qareeb rhake ga ke har waqt sirf Shirk ka dar laga rahe, har koi chalte phirte Shirk karta phire. nahi ayesa nahi hai.
kiyun ke Chaqu Churi ya Zaher se Jaan ka Dar hai, Magar Shirk se Imaan ka dar hai, aur beshak Imaan jaan se zyada Afzal hai.
To bila shuba us ki ahetyat zayada hogi jo zyada qeemti hogi…..!
Jis tarha har jaan lewa cheez aap apne azizon se door rhakte hain, usi tarha Allah ta’ala ne Shirk ko Imaan walon se door rhaka hai.
Allah hum sab ko kahne sunane se zyada Amal karne ki taufiq ata farmaye.
Mohammed imran // September 11, 2009 at 7:27 am |
Subhan allah,
allah ta’ala sab par huzoor S.A.W. Ka ta’ader saya hum sab par rakhe,Amin,
Hashmi // September 11, 2009 at 3:11 pm |
i wud firstly like to have the exact reference of the Hadith u have narrated Mr. Imran Ahmad,
and well i Wont say about Shirk as u r ryt that Shirk has been kept away from every Muslim jis k pass eeman ho,
but isnt it a very simple thing, why has prayers been kept for an eeman wala??
what are Fasts? why Do Hajj?
Allah feels very pleased when ever a Muslims Asks for anything directly from Allah.
and agar hum auliya se mangte rahe thru wasila then i guess asking directly from Allah wud leave no meaning in the hearts of people. eeman ki kamzori hoti hay logon me, mene khud dekha hay…people consider goin to mazars and all more than they would consider going For Umrah Or Hajj?
Allah has given every opportunity to a Muslim to ask directly from Allah as he is closest to us and knows the conditions of ones heart! u urself say Allah loves us more than a mother loves us ryt? then kia wo aik eeman wale ki dua qabul nahi karenge? then why consider asking the buzurgs to pray for us? amal karo ge to khuda k khud itna qareeb hojao ge that u wont need anyone else other than Allah and His Prophet’s saying and would definitly be the best of human beings! and Allah khud aik eeman k seeker ki madad karta hay agar uska intention hay seek karne ka!
iqbal ahmed // September 12, 2009 at 2:31 pm |
barelivi imam ke peechhe deobandi faith waalon ki namaaz hogi ya nahi..
Shahnawaz warsi // September 12, 2009 at 5:25 pm |
Deobandi Kehlabne walon main agar gustakh-e-Rasool Nahin hain to Unki Namaz Zarur Ho jayegi.agar woh Apne akabir Jinpar Kufr ka Fatwa laga tho ko Haqiqat main Kafir hi Mante hain Ya bilkul Jante Nahin hain.
Barelwi koi Firqa nahi hai yeh naam Sunni Aqida walon ko Deobandion ne diya hai.
Wassalam
syed minhaj ali // September 14, 2009 at 10:39 pm |
ASSALAMU ALAIKUM EVERYONE,
I ONLY WANTED TO SAY THAT BEFORE RAISING VOICE AGAINST DR.ZAKIR NAIK. PLZ SEE WAT HE IS DOING FOR SPREADING ISLAM….HE IS NOT MISGUIDING MUSLIMS RATHER HE HAS MADE SO MANY PEOPLE ACCEPT ISLAM NOT BY FORCE BUT BY JUST EXPLAINING WHAT ISLAM IS AND WHATS WRITTEN IN QURAN….IN WHICH WAY IS HE MISGUIDING CAN ANYONE TELL….IF SOMEONE IS SPREADING ISLAM NOT BY FORCE THEN PLZ SUPPORT HIM….
Umair // September 18, 2009 at 1:32 pm |
Dr. Zakir Naik holds the true knowledge of Islam. Up until now, no moulana or preacher has been able to understand the Islamic teachings rather their mind is confined to wearing SO CALLED ISLAMIC DRESSINGS and KEEPING BEARDS. It is infact these moulanas who have destroyed the true spirit of Islam.
It is indeed Dr. Zakir Naik whose speeches has touched the hearts of not only muslims but also those of non-muslims.
You can ban Dr. Zakir Naik’s programme, but he is indeed THE TRUE PREACHER OF ISLAM IN THE PRESENT TIME.
Mohd firoz // November 4, 2009 at 7:03 am |
My dear sunni brother,
Dont waist your time in Dajjal’s Fitna and safe your Aqeeda, Love Allah and His apostle and love awali-e-keram.
Ya rab na ye mane hain na manegen teri baat!!!
De inko dil aur jo na de mujhko zuban aur!!!!
Ye dajjal hain . Hujoor salallahualhiwasallam ne inke bare mein nisaniyan bata di thin usko padh kar inse bachho.
Allah bachaye dajjal se……. Ameen
Mohammed Farhan // November 7, 2009 at 9:17 am |
Assalam Alai Kum,
Dear Muslim Brothers,
I challenge all your Deobandi Ulemas to come outside and speak in front of nonmuslims. Sitting in a dark room like a rats, and issuing fatwa is very easy.
Now, listen careful. It is my FATWA that all deobandis ulemas are Munafiqs.
I have solid proof for telling them Munafiqs because like Mecca Munafiqs, these deobandi ulemas also tell Prophet Mohammed (SAW) is our nabi, but they listen to their Iman’s teaching.
Our nabi (SAW) told if Mossa ilaivosalam bhi duniya mein ajaye to bhi mera hi tareeqa chalega.
Then what about your imam who are just ummate like me and you.
Open your eyes, before they are closed.
Mohammad Ehtesham // November 12, 2009 at 1:05 pm |
Stop critisising any one DR Zakir Naik is doing right thing stop cursing him that u r ahle hadith , deobandi, jamati, look at the work he is doing in welfare of islam it has been written in HOLY QURAN Allha ki rassi ko mazbooti ke saath pakad kar rakho or aapas me firqe me na bato.